Niger - Third Highway Project

Document of The World Bank FOR OMCIL USE ONLY Repqot No. 5166 .-. PROJECT COMPLETION REPORT NIGER THIRD HIGWAY PROJET (CRE DIT 612-NM1IR) June 28, 1984 West Africa Ptojects Department Transportation Division II This docwmut m a restricd d_stihta n my be M by reients only in the perfermuce of their oicil duies. Is etenots my not oderwise be d dsetd witho Wodd Dank autboiwolrm.  FOR OMCIAL USE ONLY NIGER PROJECT COMPLETION REPORT THIRD HIGHWAY PROJECT, CR. 612 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page No. * . PREFACE ...................................... BASIC DATA SHEET .................................................. ii HIGHLIGHTS ....... ....... ......................... iii I. INTRODUCTION .................................... 1 II. PROJECT FORN LATION .................................... 1 IV. REETALUATION OF THE ECONOMIC RATE OF RETURN ..... ......... 11 V. INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMKENT ................................... 14 VI. 'BORROWER AND BANK S PERPORIANCE . ... ..... ..... .. 15 VII. IMPACT OF THE PROJECT ...................... 15 YII. CONLSONS- Coo... ....... o... 15 ANNEX:' Telex, Comments from African Development Bank ...................... 17 TABLES 1. Main Contracts Awards ..18 2. Forecast and Actual Cost ..19 3. Record of Credit Disbursement ..20 4. Economic Reevaluation - Maradi-Nigeria Border Road .21 5. Economic Reevaluation - Zinder-Nigeria Border Road .22 6. Economic Reevaluation - Maintenance Program .23 7. Cost-Benefits Streams - Overall Project .24 NAP IBRD 16335 This document has a resuictd distrbution and may be used by recpients only in the performance of their offWcial dubes Its contents may not otherwise be discned without World Bank authorization.  NIGER PROJECT COMPLETION REPORT THIRD HIGHWAY PROJECT CR.612-NIR PREFACE 1. Credit 612-NIR for the Niger Third Highway Project for US$15.6 million was signed on March 5, 1976 and was made effective on January 31, 1977. The closing date was extended by three years to June 30, 1983. The credit was fully disbursed except for about US$640,000 which will be cancelled. 2. This report was prepared by the West Africa Region Projects Department from reviews of the project files, correspondence with the borrower and the transcripts of discussions at negotiations and Board Presentation, and information gathered during missions in connection with other projects. The borrower assisted in preparation of the report by providing traffic count data used in the economic re-evaluation. 3. In accordance with the revised procedures for project perform- ance audit reporting, this Project Completion Report was read by the Operations Evaluation Department COED) but the project was not audited by OED staff. The draft report was sent to the Borrower and to the two co- financing organizations who had no comments to add (Annex). .  PIOJUCS COnFrIO 11101 SIXRD RIUECIA PIOJUC - CR. 612 KW Project Data _ _itm Actual Project costo (DoSS lon) 28.7 25.9 Overrun (5) n.. !/ Credit ammt (USS mi21o) 15.6 15.6 Disarsed 15.6 14.2 Outtandin g 14.2 Date psyicl capongtt copleted 4/79 5/83 1/ Proportion completed by targt date () - 10 Economic rate of return (S) 17 20 Cumative Z.timted and Actual Dl-btreeaoent- jUSt millon) 7177 718 717 7180 711 1182 > Apprisa estimate 6.5 11.6 14.8 15.6 - - - Actual - 5.0 9.0 12.0 13.20 14.2 15.1(out.) Actal as % of e.tiuts 0 43 61 77 84 91 97 Other Data Original Actual or pln Rewisiosm Estmated Actual Conception In Bank 1/72 Nagotiatinm 10/75 10/75 Board/Credit approval 7/75 2/17/76 Effectiveness date 9/76 1/31/77 Closing date 6/30/80 6/30181-6/30/82 06/30/83 Borrower Republic of NigCr Ecting Agency Directlon don fravauz Publics et de l'Urbanim, Fiscal Year of Borrower October 1 - Septesber 30 Follow on project Propoed Fourth Highway Project (FM83 lending program) UI