E1720 v2 Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel 9 Prediction and assessment of impact on water environment 9.1 Prediction of impact of industrial wastewater on water quality According to requirement of Clause 13, Item 2 of "Implementation of `Law of the People's Republic of China on Environment Impact Assessment' by Shanghai" on "the industrial enterprises with productive wastewater discharge rate of 1000t/d above shall be prohibited to dispose wastewater in township wastewater treatment plant but that shall dispose at the site, so as to control the discharge amount". There are two methods for discharging the wastewater of Pusteel which has been treated and up to standard, one method is to discharge into inland water, another way is to discharge into Yangtze River through Shidongkou wastewater treatment plant. Based on the two programs, the prediction of impact on water quality will be carried out respectively as follows. 9.1.1 Prediction of impact on inland water quality 9.1.1.1 Hydrodynamic model for plain tidal river network (1). Fundamental equation of hydrodynamic model The governing equation of one-dimensional hydrodynamic model for river network is a Saint-Venant equation group: A Q Q + = q t x + ( Q2 )+ gAx + g h QQ = 0 t x A C2AR (1) In the equation, the "x" and "t" refers to distance and time respectively; "A" refers to discharge section area; "Q" refers to flow rate; "h" refers to water level; "q" refers to lateral inflow; "C" refers to Chezy's coefficient; "R" refers to hydraulic radius; "" refers to momentum correction coefficient; "g" refers to acceleration of gravity. (2). Discretization of equation groups The above-mentioned control equation groups will be discreted by Abbott six-point implicit format and, the water level and flow will be calculated in turn at each grid point through the discrete format instead of calculating synchronously, 9-1 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel and the points are referred to as "h" and "Q" point (see Fig 9.1-1). This kind of format is stable unconditionally, and can be calculated stably under considerable Courant; you can select longer time step to save computing time. h Q h 7 Q h 6 5 Q 4 h 3 2 1 Fig 9.1-1 The alternative layout of Abbott format water lever and flow point Introducing storage width Bs and the continuity equation can be written as: h Q Bs + = q t x (2) Adopting the discrete format as Fig 9.1-2, the continuity equation can be written as: 2xj Timestep xj Q xj Timestep +1 xj xj Q Q +1 n+1 Q h Q Q Q n+1 h Q h n+0.5 Center point t n+0.5 t Center point 1n Q Q Q h Q n h Q h j-1 j j +1Gridpoint j -1 j j +1Grid point Water level point Flow point Fig 9.1-2 Abbott six-point central difference scheme Bs hnj - hnj (Qnj +Qnj ) 2 -(Qnj +Qnj ) 2 +1 +1 +1 + +1 +1 -1 -1 t 2xj = qj (3) 9-2 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel In similar manner, the difference type of the momentum equation at the flow point is: Qnj -Qnj +1 [ Q ]2 A n+1/2- Q2 A [ ] n+1/2 + j+1 j-1 + t 2xj [gA]nj+1/ 2(hnj+1 + hnj+1) 2-(hnj-1 + hnj-1) 2 +1 +1 + g n +1/2 2xj C2ARj QnjQn+1j= 0 (4) In certain time step, in case the flow direction at grid point has changed, then the discrete format of Q2 can be written as: Q2 Qnj Qnj -( -1)QnjQnj +1 (5) Of which: 0.5 1 After adjusting, the formula (3) can be written as: jQnj-1 + jhnj + Qnj+1 = +1 +1 +1 j j (6) After adjusting, the formula (4) can be written as: jhnj-1 + jQnj + hn+1 = +1 +1 j j+1 j (7) (3). Solution of discrete equation groups l Equationaboutriverway As previously discussed, the relationship between hydraulic parameter Z (water level: h or flow rate: Q) at any point of river way and adjacent grid point can be expressed to be a linear equation: jZnj + jZnj + Znj = +1 +1 +1 -1 j +1 j (8) The coefficient in the above formula can be calculated according to formula (6) and (7). If there is "n" grid points in riverway, as the head and end grid point are always the water level points, the "n" is an odd number. Based on the all grid point of waterway, write the formula (8), then you can get "n" linear equations: 9-3 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel 1Hus n+1 + 1h1 n+1 + 1Q2 n+1 = 1 2h1 n+1 + 2Q2 n+1 + 2h3 n+1 = 2 n-1hn-2 + n-1Qn-1 + n-1hn n+1 n+1 n+1 = n-1 nQn-1 + n+1 nhn n+1 + nHds n+1 = n (9) Of which, the Hus in the first equation and Hds in the last equation refers to the water level at the branch point of upstream and downstream. The water level at the first grid point of riverway is equivalent to that of upstream connected at the branch point: h1 = Hus , i.e.:1 = -1 1 =11 = 0 1 = 0 .Equally, hn = Hds , i.e.: n = 0 n =1n = -1n = 0. If the (boundary of upstream water level) and Hds (boundary of downstream water level) are know for single riverway, then the equation group (9) can be solved by elimination method. With regard to river network, by eliminating the functional elements of equation group (9), hydraulic parameter (water level or flow) for any points of riverway can be expressed to be function of water level at the branch point of upstream and downstream: Znj = cj - ajHus -bjHds +1 n+1 n+1 (10) Once the water level of each branch point is determined, the hydraulic parameters of any grid point can be solved by formula (10). l Branchpointequationgroups H Nodesofwater level Branch B River bank hA ,n-2 hX , j Water level, branch x point j Central line QX Node control of body , j Flow rate, branch x point j QA,n-1 Flow direction Branch A Branch C hA,n-2 QA ,n-1 hA hB ,n ,n QC ,2 hC H ,3 hC,1 9-4 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Fig 9.1-3 Equation schematic for branch point of river network As shown in Fig 9.1-3, we can get the following formula by applying the continuity equation to the control body: Hn+1 - Hn 1 n n n 1 n+1 n+1 n+1 t Afl = (QA,n-1 +QB,n-1 -QC, )+ (QA,n-1 +QB,n-1 -QC, ) 2 2 2 2 (11) Substitute the three items in second formula at the right of above-mentioned equation group with formula (10), and then we can get: Hn+1 - Hn 1 n n n 1 n+1 t Afl = (QA,n-1 +QB,n-1 -QC, )+ (cA,n-1 -aA,n-1HA,us -bA,n-1Hn+1 2 2 2 +cB,n-1 -aB,n-1HB,us -bB,n-1Hn+1 -cC, + aC, Hn+1 +bC, HC,ds) n+1 n+1 2 2 2 (12) Of which, "H" refers to water level of the branch point; HA, us and HB,us refer to water level of branch point at downstream. In formula (12), the water level of certain branch points is expressed by a liner function of water level of branch point of directly connected riverway. Also, we can get "N" similar equation groups (branch point equation group) related to all branch points (support the number is "N") of riverway. In case of the water level or flow is known, you can solve the branch point equation group by Gaussian elimination, and get the water level of branch point, which can be put into formula (10) to solve water level or flow of any grid point. l Openboundarycondition If the time change for water level is supplied in the position of boundary nodes: h=h(t).Then the branch point equation at the boundary is (suppose the numbering of riverway where the riverway located is "j"): hnj = Hus +1 n+1 +1 n+1 ,1 or hnj = Hds ,n (13) If the time change for flow is supplied in the position of boundary nodes: Q=Q(t). 9-5 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Control body h1 Qb Boundary flow H Q2 Qb h3 Q4 Fig 9.1-4 Schematic diagram of flow boundary Apply the continuity equation to the control body shown in Fig 9.1-4, and then you can get: Hn+1 - Hn 1 n n 1 n+1 n+1 t Afl = (Qb -Q2 )+ (Qb -Q2 ) 2 2 (14) Put the Q2 n+1 in formula (14) through formula (8), and then you can get: Hn -Hn +1 t Afl = (Qb -Q2 )+ (Qb -c2 +a2Hn +b2Hds ) 1 n n 1 n+1 +1 n+1 2 2 (15) If the relationship between flow and water level at the boundary point of riverway is Q=Q (h), which can be treated as that of flow boundary, then you can get the equation similar as formula (15), but the Qbn and Qb n+1 shall be achieved through the relationship between flow and water level. l Simulationof Weir andgate There are many hydraulic structures such as weir and gate built in plain river network area, where the Saint-Venant equation cannot be applied; some special treatment shall be done according hydraulic characteristics of weir and gate. Most of gate dams in river network area of Shanghai belong to broad-crested weir-type, so the weir and gate are always treated in the way of flow point; the flow can be calculated by weir or orifice flow formula of broad crested weir sluice according to relationship of adjacent water level point, and then we can get the following equation similar to formula (7). (4). Generalization of river network Shanghai is located in the Yangtze delta; its upstream water is from Taihu and 9-6 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel downstream is affected by the tide of Yangtze River mouth, and belongs to typical lake source-type plain tidal river network. In order to coordinate with the comprehensive administration planning for Tai Lake basin, the administration of water conservancy of Shanghai is divided into eleven pieces, such as Dingnan, DIngbei, Yunnan, Tainan and Taibei etc.. Now 170 or more regulating sluice, gate and hydro junction stations and 40 or more pump stations have been constructed and planned, which can form a separate water conservancy control piece to control flood-waterlogging disaster and create conditions for comprehensively treating and dispatching water sources. The river network nearby Yangsheng River will be subdivided based on original generalization river network (see Fig 9.1-5) in this environmental impact assessment, and it covers all urban-level and district-level riverway as well as part of town-level riverway in north of Jiading and Baoshan; The number of river, gate and pump station after subdivision is 295, 157 and 48 respectively. Jiabaobei Jiabaonan Yunnan Pudong 1 area TaiLake Qingsongbei Urban Dingshan lake Dingbei Pudong 2 area Shangta North of South ofQingpu Tailake and Songjiang Dingnan South of Tailake Pudong 3 area WestofPunan Pudong 4 area EastofPunan Fig 9.1-5 The diagram of river network of Shanghai (5). Calibration of hydrodynamic model Under the consideration of the calculation stability and time, the time step for calculation of the model can be set as 5 min. Based on the water level and flow data measured from more than ten sections of Huangpu River, Suzhou River and its main branch from June to September, 1999 when the third comprehensive test of water diversion on Suzhou River was carried, the hydrodynamic model of river network established is to be calibrated. Roughness coefficient is determined to be basic calibration parameters in model calibration, and for main stream of Huangpu River is 0.02-0.028, for main stream 9-7 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel of Suzhou is 0.02-0.06 and for other riverway is between 0.02 and 0.04.The comparison between calculation result and measured value of water level and flow is shown in Fig 9.1-6, 9.1-7 and 9.1-8. Fig 9.1-6 The comparison of between measured and calculated water level about main sections of Suzhou and Huangpu River 9-8 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Fig 9.1-7 The comparison of between measured and calculated flow about main sections of Suzhou and Huangpu River 9-9 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Fig 9.1-8 The comparison of flow and water level of measuring station in north of Jiabao and Yunnan It can be seen from the results of calibration in the model that, the calculated value of water level and flow for main rivers matches well with measured value, horizontal average error is less than 5% and error deviation for flow of main stream is less than 10%.Since the branch is mainly affected by control gates of each water conservancy zone, enough detailed operation data about gates are not available, thus the error from individual measuring station can be relatively great, but it shall be limited in 20%.The hydrodynamic simulation can supply relatively accurate flow conditions for model of water quality. 9-10 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel 9.1.1.2 Water quality model for plain tidal river network (1) Basic control equation The control equation of water quality model for river network is 1-dimension convection-diffusion equation, and its basic presumption is: the matters are mixed completely on the section; matters are conservational or conform to reaction kinetics; conforming to Fick diffusion law, i.e. diffusion is proportional to the concentration gradient. The one-dimensional convection-diffusion equation is: AC QC + - t x x (AD x C) = -AKC + C2q Of which: "x" and "t" refers to space coordinates (m) and time coordinate (s) respectively; "C" refers to concentration of matters (mg/L); "D" refers to longitudinal diffusivity (m2/s); "A" refers to area of cross section (m2); "q" refers to lateral inflow (m3/s); C2 refers to concentration of source/inflow (mg/L); K refers to linear attenuation coefficient (1/d). (2) The discretization and of derivation of convection diffusion equation l Thediscretizationof convectiondiffusionequation In order to reduce numerical discretization and ensure the conservation of mass, the time and space center implicit difference scheme can be used for discretization of convection diffusion equation, and then according to the control volume listed in Fig 9.1-9 to deduce the discretization format of convection diffusion equation. q, CLAT QA QC j-1 A C j+2 xj xj +1 9-11 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Fig 9.1-9 Schematic diagram of the control volume for convection diffusion process Vjn+1/ 2Cnj+1- Vj n+1/ 2Cnj t t +Tj+1 -Tj-1 = qnj n+1/ 2 n+1/ 2 +1/ 2 n+1/ 2 / 2 / 2 C2j -Vj n+1/ 2KjCnj Of which: "j" refers to number of grid; "n" refers to time step; "t" refers to volume; "T" refers to the conveying capacity through control volume; "Cq" refers to concentration of lateral inflow matters. The discretization format of convection diffusion equation is: +1/ 2 -Cnj +1/ 2 Tj n+1/ 2 +1/ 2 = Qnj +1/ 2 +1/ 2 C*j +1/ 2- Anj+1/ 2 Cnj+1 +1/ 2 D x +1/ 2 Of which: x refers to space step; Qnj +1/ 2 refers to flow through right side wall +1/2 of control volume; Anj+1/ 2 refers to cross-sectional area of right side wall; C*j+1/ 2 refers to interpolate concentration value of upstream, and can be calculated as the following: C*j +1/ 2= (Cnj + Cnj + Cnj + Cnj ) - min(16 (1+ 1 +1 +1 2 1 +1 +1 ), 4 2 4 )(Cnj -2Cnj +Cnj ) +1 -1 In the formula, the refers to Kelang, = ut x. Collate the above-mentioned formulas and you can get any time step; the implicit difference equation related to the concentration of adjacent three grid points is: jCnj + jCnj + Cnj = +1 +1 +1 -1 j +1 j The condition for open boundary outflow: 2C x2 = 0 If the outflow boundary turns into inflow boundary, please refer to the following formula: 9-12 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel C = Cbf +(Cout -Cbf )e-tmixKmix Of which: Cbf refers to incoming boundary concentration; Cout refers to the boundary concentration prior to changing of flow direction; Kmix refers to time scale determined during incoming; tmixrefers to the time calculated from the changing of flow direction. The characteristics under closed boundary are that no flow and exchange of matters happening on the boundary: Q = 0 and C x = 0 . The above-mentioned equation groups can be solved by "double-scan method", which the same with hydrodynamic model. (3) Process model for water quality change The migration and transformation of organic pollutants in rivers, especially for water pollutants, is a complex physical, chemical and biological process; see Fig 9.1-10. BOD, NH + + N2 Sunshine 4 pollution load Air reoxygenation Denitrify Nitration NO3- Convection- + DO diffusion NH4 - Sol ubl e Convection- diffusion Soluble BOD BOD Suspended BOD Deposition Suspended + Photosynthesis process - resuspension BOD Sedimentary BOD matter Sedimentary Sediment oxygen BOD - demand - Respiration Fig 9.1-10 The schematic drawing of water quality change The physical process: process of plug flow shift, turbulent diffusion and dispersion of pollutants along with river water; adsorbing, desorbing, depositing and resuspending with suspended mud and sand particles; heat transfer and evaporation of pollutants as well as transport of bed mud with pollutants as carrier. The biochemical process includes non - oxygen and oxygen stages, of 9-13 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel which, the oxygen process includes oxidative decomposition of carbon and nitrogen containing compound. Non-oxygen process includes denitrogenation reaction; the nitrate nitrogen in water will be reduced to nitrite nitrogen, and at last forms nitrogen. (4) Coupling calculation of water quality change and convection diffusion process The coupling calculation process about water quality change and convection diffusion is as follows: Calculate concentration ( Cn +1,AD) of water quality constituents at n+1 time step through convection diffusion module; Calculatetheconcentrationgradient LCn +1,AD = (Cn+1,AD -Cn )/ Lt ,AD caused by convection diffusion; Calculatetheconcentration Cn +1,WQof water quality constituents at "n+1" time step through water quality module; Calculate the concentration gradient LCn +1,WQ = (Cn +1,WQ-Cn )/ Lt ,WQ caused by water quality change; Calculatethetotalconcentrationgradient LCn +1,WQ = LCn +1,WQ + LCn+1,AD; Integrate the calculation result in step 5 through 5- order Runge-Kutta method, and then the concentration of matter in this time step can be got. (5) Generalization of model river network The generalized river network of water quality model shall be in accordance with hydrodynamic model. (6) Calculation of pollution load At present, there are many sources of pollutions discharged directly in Shanghai; with the help of GIS tools and by statistical analysis and based on the whereabouts of the sewage discharge, and the principle of discharge nearby, converting the point pollution sources of Shanghai into boundary documents of water quality model. With the scope of research, LOAD module is to be used to estimate the non-point source pollution load which divided according to water conservancy zones, by carrying out statistical analysis about land use, amount of precipitation, 9-14 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel population density and other pollution data of each collecting basin, and then calculating the pollution load. (7) Calibration and verification of the model As lack of simultaneous monitoring data about water quality in north of Jiading and Baoshan District, the calibration of river network water quality model will be carried out according to the data about the water quality of Huangpu River, Suzhou River and their main branch measured from June to September, 1999 when the third comprehensive test of water diversion on Suzhou River was carried. The main parameters and result for model calibration is shown in Table 1.The comparison between calculation and measured result of main water quality indicators about typical section is shown from Fig 9.1-11 to 9.1-14. 9-15 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Table 9.1-11 Comparison between model calibration and experimental results of main parameters of water quality COD BOD Water quality Longitudinal degradation degradation Reaeration Sediment oxygen parameters dispersion coefficient coefficient coefficient coefficient (g O2)/m2/d) (1/d) (1/d) (1/d) Calibration results 515 0.050.2 0.10.3 0.1~0.4 16 Experimental results 535 00.25 0.050.8 0.755 Fig 9.1-11 The comparison between measured and calculated concentration of water quality of Huangdu 9-16 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Fig 9.1-12 The comparison between measured and calculated concentration of water quality of Beixinjing 9-17 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Fig 9.1-13 The comparison between measured and calculated concentration of water quality of Zhejiang Road Bridge 9-18 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Fig 9.1-14 Comparison between measured and calculated DO value of mainstream and branch of Suzhou River From the results that we know, the calculated values are basically the same with measured values with the average error within 20%. Since the branch is mainly affected by control gates of each water conservancy zone, while enough detailed and exact operation data about gates and data of pollution load are not available, which causes big error between calculated and measured concentration of water quality from individual measuring station; however the most of errors still are permissible and can conform to the requirements of engineering. 9.1.1.3 Water quality simulation program (1) Selection of hydrographic conditions 9-19 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel It is about to select hydrodynamic conditions and rainfall data of dry season in typical dry year (1971) of Shanghai as hydrographic conditions in this model. (2) The water diversion program about north of Jiading and Baoshan District The water diversion program (introduced from north and supplied to the east) and water flow direction is shown in Fig 9.1-15. Liu River D e s i g n e d sewage outfall Yangtze Yangsheng River estuary Lianqi River Panjing Yangsheng River Yunzaobang Suzhou River Fig 9.1-15 The water diversion program about north of Jiading and Baoshan District (introducing water from north and supplied to the east) (3) Water quality simulation program The sewerage produced in this environmental impact assessment will be discharged from plant moat of Pusteel through Yangsheng River; Table 9.1-2 shows the water quality simulation program. Table 9.1-2 Water quality simulation program for inland river network Water Hydrological Sewage The discharge Simulation No. diversion computation treatment amount and standard water quality mode conditions station of planned by other local Pusteel plants indicators Amount of sewage: 6240 Amount of sewage: Non-water m3/d 8020 m3/d CODCr, BOD5 diversion / Dry season Class III Class II discharge and discharge standard of Shanghai petroleum oil standard Water Introduced Amount of Amount of sewage: CODCr, BOD5 diversion from the Dry season sewage: 6240 8020 m3/d and north and m3/d Class II discharge petroleum oil 9-20 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel supplied Class I standard of Shanghai to the east discharge standard 9.1.1.4 Result analysis of water quality simulation (1) Prediction and analysis of the influence on water quality of river network In case of non-water diversion, the maximum incremental distribution of concentration of pollutants discharged into Suitang and Yangsheng River by Pusteel and planned project is shown in Fig 9.1-16 and 9.1-17. Program for non-water diversion -- diagram for CODCr concentration increment Water diversion program-- diagram for CODCr concentration increment Fig 9.1-16 Distribution forecast of CODCr concentration for river network 9-21 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Program for non-water diversion -- diagram for BOD5 concentration increment Water diversion program-- diagram for BOD5 concentration increment Fig 9.1-17 Distribution forecast of BOD5 concentration for each river network From the diagrams you can see that no matter whether or not the implementation of water diversion program, the riverway influenced by pollutions is limited to the river network to the east of Panjing and north of Yunzaobang, among which the pollution of riverway near the sewage outfalls at Yangsheng River, West Suitang River, Gujing and Wuyue Pool etc. are relatively obvious. After the implementation of water diversion, the sewage will spread over the south of Yangsheng River along with water flow, and this will expand the range of polluted river network to some extent; however the increment of average concentration of pollutants in river network near the sewage outfalls dropped. 9-22 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel (2) Predication of the impact on water quality of Yangsheng River The concentration increment of CODCr and BOD5 discharged into Yangsheng River (from West Suitang River to Yunzaobang) from tail water of sewage outfalls is shown in Fig 9.1-18 and Fig 9.1-19. 40 )L/gm(noitartnecnocDOC 35 Water standard for Class IV 30 Non water diversion water diversion 25 20 Water standard for Class II tnemercni15 10 5 0 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Distance from West Suitang River (Km) West Suitang D e s i g n e d River sewage outfall Gujing LianqiRiver Meipu River Yunzaobang Fig 9.1-18 The average concentration increment of CODCr along Yangsheng River 10 )L/gm(tnemercninoitartnecnoc5DOC 8 Water standard for Class IV Non water water diversion diversion 6 4 Water standard for Class II 2 0 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Distance from West Suitang River (Km) West Suitang D e s i g n e d River sewage outfall Gujing LianqiRiver Meipu River Yunzaobang Fig 9.1-19 The average concentration increment of BOD5 along Yangsheng River The statistical data related to the length of river reach where the concentration increment has exceeded certain value is shown in Table 9.1-3, 9.1-4 and 9.1-5. It shall be noted that the statistical results in the table are only applicable to Yangsheng River and Xitang River, not to other small riverway connected to Yangsheng River such as Wuyue Pool and Gujing; therefore the actual length of river network influenced by pollutions shall be longer than that of listed in the table. Table 9.1-1 Length statistics (CODCr) of polluted river reach of Yangsheng River Unit: km 9-23 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Simulation program Non-water diversion Water diversion Concentration increment CODCr > 30 mg/L 1.0 / CODCr > 20 mg/L 1.8 1.0 CODCr > 15 mg/L 2.5 1.5 CODCr> 10 mg/L 3.6 3.0 CODCr > 5 mg/L 5.6 3.8 Note: the "slash" in the table refers to the length of polluted river reach is less than the length of a grid (approx. 200m) in generalize river network of the model. The following is the same as. Table 9.1-1 Length statistics (BOD5) of polluted river reach of Yangsheng River Unit: km Simulation program Concentration increment Non-water diversion Water diversion BOD5 > 6.0 mg/L 1.0 / BOD5 > 4.0 mg/L 1.7 1.0 BOD5 > 3.0 mg/L 2.0 1.4 BOD5 > 2.0 mg/L 2.4 2.6 BOD5 > 1.0 mg/L 5.4 3.5 From the table we can see: l If the implementation of water diversion has not been done under hydrological conditions in dry season, the water quality of water reach near Yangsheng River and West Suitang River will be influenced obviously by pollutions planned: the length of water reach in which the concentration increment of CODCr exceeding 30 mg/L is approx. 1Km, and exceeding 20 mg/L is approx 1.8 Km; the length of water reach in which the concentration increment of BOD5 exceeding 6.0 mg/L is 1.0 Km, and exceeding 4.0 mg/Lis 1.7 Km. Even if the background concentration has not been considered, the concentration of CODCr and BOD5 in the approx 1km length water reach of Yangsheng River still exceeds the water quality standard of Class IV under the conditions of planning sewage. 9-24 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel l As compared to the program of non-water diversion, the water diversion in dry season can reduce the concentration increment of pollutants in Yangsheng River and adjacent riverway under the conditions of planning sewage; so even if the program of water diversion is carried, the planning sewage will still bring out negative influence on the water quality of Yangsheng River and adjacent riverway. 9.1.1.5 Calculation and analysis on water environmental capacity of Yangshen River According to the designed hydrological condition, location of sewage outfalls, volume and quality of sewage, the constrain condition and objective condition for designed water quality, the maximum permissible pollution emissions in river reach for Pusteel' s planned project can be calculated. (1) Calculation method about water environmental capacity The computational model about water environmental capacity of river network pollutants can be established based on the basic equation of water volume and quality. The one-dimensional convection-diffusion equation for river is: (AC) (QC) + = (ADx )- KAC + qCq C t x x Where: "C" refers to the concentration of pollutant; "K" refers to degradation coefficient of pollutant; "q" refers to lateral inflow; Cq refers to inflow concentration; "D" refers to longitudinal dispersion coefficient. The computational formula for water environmental capacity can be got by simplifying and deducing the convection-diffusion equation: WL = Q0(CS -C0) + qCS + KVCS WLrefers to permissible emissions; the pollutant degradation coefficient (K) can be from experimental analysis or from calibration result of water quality model. The above-mentioned formula is applicable for computing steady capacity and dynamic capacity, and it is also applicable for computing the capacity of a one-way river and water environmental capacity of tidal river network. When use the formula to compute water environmental capacity of tidal river, the inflow rate Q0 shall be treated. 9-25 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel In the case of tidal river, the movement of L river reach can be divided into the following four typical forms: q q Q1 Q2 Q1 Q2 V V L L (1) (2) q q Q1 Q2 Q1 Q2 V V L L (3) (4) Fig 9.1-20 The schematic diagram for to-and-fro flow of tide For the first flow form:Q0 = Q1, the second: Q0 = Q2 , the third: Q0 = Q1 +Q2 and the fourth: Q0 = 0. If a river is divided into "n" segments, and supposes that the permissible emissions in the "i" river reach is Wi , then the permissible emissions for the whole river are: n W Wi i=1 For non-constant flow, not only shall the change of permissible discharge amount of pollutants along with place be considered, but also with time. Suppose the time "T" to be divided into "m" time interval, then the permissible discharge amount in time "T" can be set as: Tmt In the moment "j" and the "i" river reach, if the permissible discharge amount isWij , then the permissible discharge amount for the river in time "T" is: 9-26 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel m n W W ijtj j=1 i=1 (2) Selection of control index According to wastewater pollution analysis and regional pollution of Pusteel, and the stipulations of "Overall Scheme for Controlling National Total Amount of Pollutants", the CODCr, BOD5 and petroleum oil are selected as total amount control indexes in this environmental impact assessment. (3) Calculation program and selection of parameters l Standards for water quality According to layout of water function, the water quality of Yangsheng River shall meet Class IV water standard. l When the water diversion is not carried, the boundary inflow water quality shall be in accordance with Class IV of water quality. Under the conditions of water diversion, it shall be in accordance with Class II-III of water quality. l Designedhydrological condition With the help of the hydrological conditions of typical dry year (1971) and by the calculation of capacity model based on simulation results from hydrodynamic model of river network, the hydrodynamic data such as flow rate, volume and flow velocity can be got. (4) Calculation programs From the calculation formula of environmental capacity we can see that the water environmental capacity of certain river reach depends on objective concentration of water quality, inflow rate and concentration of water quality, water volume of river reach and degradation coefficient of pollutants etc. In this environmental impact assessment, the water environmental capacity of Yangsheng River is calculated and analyzed under the conditions of two programs which are non-water diversion program and the program of introducing water from north and supplied to the east. (5) Analysis on results of capacity calculation The calculation results for water environmental capacity of Yangsheng River (water reach from West Suitang River to Gujing River) are shown in Table 9.1-5. Table 9.1-5 The water environmental capacity of Yangsheng River (water reach 9-27 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel from West Suitang River to Gujing River) Water quality Planned emissions Permissible emissions (t/d) index (t/d) Non-water diversion Water diversion CODcr 1.30 0.65 1.25 BOD5 0.433 0.13 0.25 Petroleum oil 0.12 0.01 0.03 From the table we can see that under the hydrological conditions in dry season, the permissible emissions at the sewage outfall of Yangsheng River under implementation of water diversion are higher than that of non-water diversion. Under the implementation of water diversion, the water environmental capacity of Yangsheng River reach near the designed sewage outfall (water reach from West Suitang River to Gujing River) is1.25 t/d for CODCr, 0.25 t/d for BOD5 and 0.03 t/d for petroleum oil. The permissible emissions of CODCr, BOD5 and petroleum oil can not meet the designed requirements. 9.1.2 Prediction of impact on water quality of Yangtze River estuary 9.1.2.1 Plane 2-dimension hydrodynamic model of Yangtze River estuary The ocean dynamic characteristics of waters are necessary for establishing hydrodynamic mode of estuary and bay. For sea area with shallow water and even mixing of sea water, two-dimension mathematical model with average water depth can be adopted. The 2-dimension plain hydrodynamic model and convection-diffusion model (MIKE21) adopted in this study are used for analyzing the transport and diffusion of pollutants discharged into Yangtze River estuary .The hydrodynamic simulation is used for supplying the flow field needed for calculating water quality in water quality mode; the convection-diffusion model is used for quantitative analysis of the sewage impact, and used for assessing the location of sewage outfall and its treatment level according to the water quality of sensitive waters. (1) Control equation of hydrodynamic model Under the consideration of Bousinesque approximation and shallow assumptions as well as the impact of wind stress, the two-dimension hydrodynamic equation groups for vertical integration is: Continuity equation: 9-28 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel p q t + x + y = S Momentum equation: p p2 gp p2+ q2 + + gh + t x h y pq + h x C2h2 - 1 h (pa)= 0 w x (h xx)+ (h xy) - q - fVVx + y w x q q2 gq p2+ q2 + + gh + t y h x pq + h y C2h2 - 1 + p - fVV + h (pa)= 0 w y (h yy)+ (h xy) x y w y In the formula: "h" refers to water depth (m); "p, q" refers to single-wide flow at x, y direction (m3/s/m); C = H1 16 n refers to Chezy' s coefficient, "n" refers to Manning coefficient; " " refers to wind resistance coefficient; f V,Vx,Vy refers to wind speed (m/s); refers to Coriolis parameter; pa refers to air pressure (Kg/m/s2); w refers to water density (Kg/m3); xx, xy, yy refers to shearing stress components; For MIKE 21, the ADI method is used for solving the above-mentioned equation groups. (2) Scope of model In this environmental impact assessment, big and medium models are established, and their scopes are shown in Fig 9.1-21; the relationship between models and their 9-29 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel usage is shown in Table 9.1-6. Fig 9.1-21 Model diagram of Yangtze River estuary and Hangzhou Bay Table 9.1-6 The scope, grid division and purpose of model Number Model Scope Grid size Intended use of grid 1. Used for calibration and verification of parameters of hydrodynamic Yangtze River Large model and water quality model; estuary and 500m*500m 510*596 model Hangzhou Bay 2. Used for supplying hydrodynamic force, water quality boundary and initial conditions. Yangtze estuary 3. Used for simulating the water quality of tail water discharged into downstream of the Yangtze River estuary by Medium Chongtou and 150m*150m 421*151 Pusteel model upstream of Nanbeigang, 4. Used for statistical analysis of the area and length of pollution belt Changxing island near the sewage outfall. 9-30 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel (3) Boundary conditions of model Waters open boundary: select the given tide level, and estimate by amplitude and phase from eleven tidal components. Boundary of river: the rivers in the scope of the study include Yangtze River, Qiantang River, Huangpu River, Cao'ejiang and Yongjiang etc., among which the observed data is selected for Yangtze River, for other rivers, the average flow rate for years in dry and flood season is selected. (4) Calibration and verification of the model The calibration and verification of hydrodynamic model is based on the measured data such as tide level, flow rate, flow speed and direction etc. from typical measuring points of Yangtze River and Hangzhou Bay when measured from March to September, 2002. The hydrodynamic test results are shown from Fig 9.1-22 to Fig 9.1-25. Luchao harbor 5.0 4.0 )m(levelretawm 3.0 2.0 1.0 0.0 )m(levelretaw -1.0 9-20 9-22 9-24 9-26 9-28 Calculated data Actual measured data date Zhongjun 5.0 4.0 m ( 3.0 e e )mlevlretaw 2.0 )m(l 1.0 0.0 velretaw -1.0 9-22 9-23 9-24 9-25 9-26 9-27 9-28 Calculated data Actual measured data date Fig 9.1-22 The verification results for water level of Luchao harbor and Zhongjun 9-31 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Nangang 120000 A c t u a l 90000 measured data Calculated data 60000 )s/ 30000 33 )/ m(eta m( 0 3-1 6:00 3-2 6:00 3-3 6:00 3-4 6:00 3-5 6:00 r -30000 wolF -60000 -90000 -120000 -150000 Beigang 1 2 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 A u a l c t measured data Calculated data 6 0 0 0 0 etarwolF 3 0 0 0 0 0 - 3 030-010 1 2 : 0 0 3 - 2 1 2 : 0 0 3 - 3 1 2 : 0 0 3 - 4 1 2 : 0 0 3 - 5 1 2 : 0 0 - 6 0 0 0 0 - 9 0 0 0 0 - 1 2 0 0 0 0 - 1 5 0 0 0 0 Fig 9.1-23 The verification results for flow rate of Nangang and Beigang Y4 middletide flow velocity Y4 2.0 )s/m(yticolevwolF)s/m( Calculated Actual measured 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 3-5 10:48 3-5 20:24 3-6 6:00 3-6 15:36 Date Y4middletideflow direction Y4 450 )eerged(noitceridwolF) 360 ( 270 180 90 Calculated Actual measured 0 3-5 9:36 3-5 20:24 3-6 7:12 3-6 18:00 Date Fig 9.1-24 The verification results for flow direction of Qiyakou 9-32 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Y8 middle tide flow velocity Y 8 2 . 0 yticolevwolF Calculated Actual measured 1 . 5 1 . 0 0 . 5 0 . 0 3 - 4 9 : 3 6 3 - 4 1 9 : 1 2 3 - 5 4 : 4 8 3 - 5 1 4 : 2 4 Date Y8middletide flow direction Y 8 4 5 0 htmpedretaW 3 6 0 2 7 0 1 8 0 9 0 0 3 - 4 1 0 : 4 8 3 - 4 2 0 : 2 4 3 - 5 6 : 0 0 3 - 5 1 5 : 3 6 Calculated Actual measured Date Fig 9.1-25 The verification results for flow rate and flow direction of Beigang The calculated value is basically same with measured value, and it can reflect the flow-field characteristics of Yangtze River estuary waters, so the value can provide exact hydrodynamic conditions for Lagrange drift and simulation of water quality. 9.1.2.2 Plane 2-Dimension water quality model of Yangtze River estuary and Hangzhou Bay The basic equation for 2-dimension convection-diffusion model is: C +u C + v C 2C 2C t x y = Kx x2 + Ky y2 Of which: " C " refers to substance concentration (mg/L); " u,v" refers to the flow rate component at the direction of x, y (m/s); " Kx,Ky " refers to turbulent dispersion coefficient at the direction of x, y (m2/s). The 2D UPWIND is used for discretizing the above-mentioned equation and solving the convection-diffusion equation. The hydrodynamic model is used for calculating flow field, and the convection 9-33 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel diffusion model is used for analyzing the permissible emissions and forecasting the incremental concentration of pollutants in various conditions and distribution characteristics. 9.1.2.3 Water quality simulation program In this environmental impact assessment, the typical hydrological conditions in dry season (from January to March, 2004) is utilized as hydrological conditions for simulation of water quality, and the most unfavorable period is at the time of neap tide in dry season. Waters open boundary: select the given tide level, and estimate by amplitude and phase from eleven tidal components Upstream boundary of Yangtze River: adopting the measured flow rate of Jangyin station from January to March, 2004; for other rivers such as Qiangtang River, Huangpu River, Cao'e River and Yongjiang, the average flow rate for years in dry season is adopted. Water quality boundary: in this environmental impact assessment, only the simulation of incremental concentration of discharged tail water by Pusteel is carried, so the concentration of water quality in upstream boundary of Yangtze River, boundary of open sea and inflow of other rivers is selected as zero. Index of water quality: CODcr and BOD5. 9.1.2.4 Analysis on results of water quality simulation The tail water of Pusteel is discharged into Yangtze River estuary through discharge pipe of Shidongkou, and the distribution diagrams for concentration increment of pollutants in waters near outfall are shown in Fig 9.1-26 and 9.1-27. From the simulation results, we can see that under unfavorable hydrological conditions, no obvious pollution belt will be formed in waters near sewage outfall, and the pollutions only have a little impact on the water quality of sensitive waters such as "Chongming water source protection zone", "Qingcaosha water source protection zone" and "Chenhang water source protection zone", e.g. the average concentration increment of CODcr in "Chenhang water source protection zone" is less than 0.01 mg/L, which is negligible compared to the background concentration of water quality in this waters and is far from sufficient to change the classification of water quality. 9-34 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel 9.1.2.5 Analysis on compatibility, feasibility and rationality of combined discharge of industrial wastewater and wastewater from Shidongkou wastewater treatment plant (1) Wastewater treatment scope for Shidongkou wastewater treatment plant According to "Planning for Wastewater Specialty in Shanghai", the designed wastewater treatment system of Shidongkou is responsible for collecting and transporting of the sanitary sewage and industrial wastewater from Baoshan urban area north to Yunzaobang and the area south to Yunzaobang, west to Gonghexin Road, north to Lingshi Road and Wenshui Road, east to outer ring as well as Nanxiang, Jiangqiao and Fenbang area in Jiading District, these sewage will be discharged into Yangtze River after secondary treatment by Shidongkou wastewater treatment plant; the designed sewage treatment volume is 810,000 m3/d. ChongmingIsland water resource protection zone qingcaoshawater resource protection zone Chenhangwater resourceprotectionzone Maximal concentration increment ChongmingIslandwater resource protection zone qingcaosha water resource protection zone Chenhang water resource protection zone Average concentration increment Fig 9.1-26 The distribution diagram for concentration increment of CODCr in dry season 9-35 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel Chongming Island water resourceprotection zone qingcaosha water resource protectionzone Chenhang water resource protection zone Maximal concentration increment Chongming Islandwater resource protection zone qingcaosha water resource protection zone Chenhang water resource protection zone Average concentration increment Fig 9.1-27 The distribution diagram for concentration increment of BOD5 in dry season The original treatment capacity for Shidongkou wastewater treatment plant is 800,000m3/d, and meanwhile the "Construction Project Environmental Impact Report" is available. Under the consideration that the treatment capacity of 800,000m3/d can bring certain influence to the Chenghang reservoir upstream and Qingcaosha water source downstream, so the treatment capacity of Shidongkou wastewater treatment plant is defined to 400,000m3/d, and it is responsible for the area north to Yunzaobang and partial area south to Yunzaobang; Considering the relevance between the plant and the first-phase combined wastewater system, the other wastewater of approx.400,000m3/d produced from south of Yunzaobang will be accessed into first-phase combined wastewater system and then conveyed to Zhuyuan, Pudong, where a large-scale wastewater treatment plant with treatment capacity of 1,200,000m3/d is being built. (2) Compatibility, feasibility and rationality analysis on combined discharge. The Shidongkou wastewater treatment plant is located on the Yangtze riverbank of Shidongkou, Yuepu Town, Baoshan District, with the designed treatment capacity is 400,000m3/d while the actual is 320,000m3/d at present. The 9-36 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel wastewater treatment process for the plant is AAO process. The tail water from the plant is discharged by No.5 pump station, 400m offshore and 5m under water surface of Yangtze River. The industrial wastewater discharged for this project is 6,240m3/d; if discharging these wastewater into inland water, this will increase the pollution degree of inland water; in case of discharging into wastewater treatment plant, this will be subject to the stipulations of Clause 13, Item 2 of "Implementation of `Law of the People' s Republic of China on Environment Impact Assessment' by Shanghai" about "the industrial enterprises with productive wastewater discharge rate of 1000t/d above shall be prohibited to dispose wastewater in township wastewater treatment plant but that shall dispose at the site, so as to control the discharge amount"; in case of discharging into Yangtze River by self-setting sewage outfall, this will not be approved by Shanghai Water Sector. For the above reasons, the program that takes advantage of the tail pipe of Shidongkou wastewater treatment plant for discharge of industrial wastewater from Pusteel, which not only can the discharge of industrial wastewater be guaranteed, but also can meet the stipulation of "Implementation of `Law of the People's Republic of China on Environment Impact Assessment' by Shanghai" and the requirements of Shanghai Water Sector; furthermore, there is no technical problem between implementation of the program and the discharge of Shidongkou wastewater treatment plant. From the above we can see that the implementation of combined discharge of the wastewater from this project and Shidongkou wastewater treatment plant is feasible and reasonable. 9.1.3 Summary (1) Under the hydrological conditions in dry season, the tail water of Pusteel discharged into Yangsheng River will bring a greater impact on water quality of Yangsheng River, West Suitang River and nearby riverway; after the implementation of water diversion, although the water quality of river network nearby the sewage outfall has been improved to some extent, the effect is not obvious and the impact on water quality is still evident. If the implementation of water diversion has not been done, the water quality of water reach near Yangsheng River and West Suitang River will be influenced obviously by pollutions planned: the length of water reach in which the concentration increment of CODCr exceeding 30 mg/L is approx. 1Km, and exceeding 20 mg/L is approx 1.8 Km; the length of water reach in which the concentration increment of BOD5 exceeding 6.0 mg/L is 1.0 Km, and exceeding 4.0 mg/L is 1.7 Km. Even if the background concentration has not been considered, the concentration of CODCr and BOD5 in the approx 1km length water reach of Yangsheng River still exceeds the water quality standard of Class IV under the conditions of planning sewage. 9-37 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel (2) Comparing to the situation without the water diversion program, the program in dry season can help decrease to some extent the concentration of pollutants in Yangsheng River waters and nearby waters under the planned discharge condition. So the designed waste discharge will still present significantly a diverse effect on the water quality in Yangsheng River and nearby waters even the water diversion program is implemented. (3) The water diversion program is able to increase the water environment capacity of Yangsheng River to some extent, but the amount of discharged BOD5 and petroleum oil is still larger than that in the planned river reach (the river reach of Yangsheng River from West Suitang River to Gujing). (4) In dry season or under unfavorable hydrological conditions, the tail water discharged by Pusteel will not form a polluted zone significantly in the waters nearby the sewage outfall and it may present little effect on the water quality of the sensitive waters in "Chenhang water resource protection area". And the concentration can be ignored compared to the background water concentration in the area and far from sufficient to change the type of water quality in the area. It is recommended in this appraisal that the tail water discharge at the Yangtze estuary is available. 9.2 Assessment for impact of warm water discharge on Yangtze River In this environmental impact assessment, the far-field simulation (MIKE21) and near-field simulation (Plume) is conducted on the situation of warm water discharged by Pusteel. The far-field simulation is used for forecasting the influence range of warm water discharge and impact on nearby sensitive waters under designed hydrological conditions, and the far-field numerical simulation includes the process of: heat convection, heat diffusion, heat radiation and the heat exchange between water body and air; the near-field simulation is used for forecasting the situation of dilution and diffusion of warm water belt and change of vertical water temperature at typical tidal current moment, and the hydrodynamic design parameters (flow velocity ad water depth etc.) needed for near-field simulation can be got from the results of far-field simulation. 9.2.1 Far-field simulation of warm water discharge 9.2.1.1 Control equation The basic equation for water temperature field is 2-dimension convection-diffusion model: 9-38 PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com Environmental Impact Report on Pusteel Relocation Engineering of Baosteel T + u T + v T 2T 2(T) + Q t x y = Kx x2 + Ky y2 HwCw Where, T refers to temperature of water body (
Группа Всемирного банка · Environmental Assessment
China - Luojing COREX Carbon Finance Project (Vol. 2 of 2) : Environmental impact report on relocation engineering
Открыть оригинал документа
Полный текст размещён на сайте публикующей организации. lawenc.com индексирует метаданные и ведёт на официальный источник.
Полный текст
Основные сведения
Организация
Группа Всемирного банка
Тип документа
Environmental Assessment
Страна
Китай
Источник
Всемирный банк