India - Punjab Irrigation Project

Document of The World Bank FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Report No. 7834 PROJECT COMPLETION REPORT INDIA PUNJAB IRRIGATION PROJECT (CREDIT 889-IN) JUNE 21, 1989 Asia Regional Office Ti document hau a rested dibtriution and may be used by redplents only In the perfrmane of their offlch du&-s Its contes may not otvise be dilosed wiot Wodd Bank sudhoraon.  Banr Govunment Of lndi Execuling ecy Government of Punpab FucalYear April 'st to March 31st Nameof Curn Rupe Apisal yew (averge) US$1.00 * Rs 8.60 ntaveni!g yew (avng) US$1.00 Rs 10.034 (Yew 1983) Compleoy(aveg) US$1.00 = Rs 12.36 GLOSSARY Branch and - BlTigaon canal with capacity more than 0.7 m3/s Distributary originating at the main canal canal Chak - Block or nrigaon srvice area below the Governent outlet Field Chanel - Irigation channel from the Government (chak) oudet to individual farms (with lcfs - 28 U/sec - discharge) Kharif - Wet season. (June to October) Main Canal - Main conveyance systems originating at the water source (dam, river) Rabi - Winter Season (November to March) Warabandi - Rotational Water Supply (RWS) used in nordtem India and based on allocation of water in proporton to the size of the landholding and delivery at predeined tums  FOR OFFICIL US ONLY THE WORLD BSA Washmnton. D.C. 2033 U.S.A. Offi c M Diwr-cwGswaf June 21, 1989 MEMORANDUM TO THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS AND TdE PRESIDENT SUBJECTs Project Completion Report on India Punjab Irritation Prolect (Credit 889-IN) Attached, for information, is a copy of a report entitled 'Project Completion Report on India Punjab Irrigation Project (Credit 889-IN)" prepared by the Government of Punjab, with an overview memorandum prepared by the Asia Regional Office. No audit of this project has been made by the Operations Evaluation Department at this time. Yves Rovani by Ram K. Chopra Attachment IThis docutnent has a resukted disiribution and tnay be used by dpients only in tb e ffortace| of their offitcial duties. Its contents mnay not otherwise be dWissbod witbout World Bank autbootL  FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLI PROJECT COMPLETION REPORT INDIA PUNJAB IRRIGATION PROJECT (CREDIT 889-IN) TABLE OF CONTENTS Page No. Prefacoo oooot t. O.... .0* ..... i Basic Data Sheet .................................*................ 1i Evaluation Summary, .............. ii II. THE PROJECT AT APPRAISAL 4 III. PROJECT IPLEMENTATION.. 8 IV. INSTITUTIONAL PERFORMANCE .................... 22 V. AGRICULTURAL IMPACT 26 VI. BANK PERFORMANCE*...................... 31 VII. ISSUES AND LESSONS LEARNTE................ ..... 32 Table 1 - Statement of Covenants Annexes 1 Statements Showing Performance of Lined Canals 2 District-wise Area under Crops and Produce (For Sangrur, Ferosepur, Bhatinda & Faridkot) 3 Statements Showing Irrigation Potential on Lined Canals 4 Statement Showing Systems Losses in Unlined Condition 5 Studies and Pilot Demonstration Schemes Attachment I - Borrower Comments This documnent has a restricted distribution and may be used by recipiefts only in the perfomiance of their official duties. Its contents may not otherwise be disclosed without World Bank authorization.  INDIA PUNLJAB iRRIGATION PRQJEC1 (CREDIT 889-IN) PROJET COMPLETION REPORT Peface This Project Completion Report (PCR) reviews implementation of the Punjab rigation Project in India for which Credit 889-IN in the amount of US$ 129 million was approved on March 29, 1979. The credit was closed on June 30, 1986; the Credit was fully disbursed The PCR was prepared by the Government of Punjab (GOP). The Evaluation Sum=my and Overview supplement the GOP PCR with IDA's observations giving special attention to points and issues not fully covered. The Overview, prepared by Asia Region staff, is based on the PCR, the Staff Appraisal Report (No. 2339-IN, dated March 19,1979, President's Report (No. P-2466- IN of the same date), Development Credit Agreement, dated March 30, 1988, Bank supervision rmission reports, and discussions with Government of Punjab officials. This PCR was read by the Operations Eraluation Department (OED). The draft PCR was sent to the Borrower for comments and they are attached to the R"eport (Attachment I).  - PN - (CREDfrf 94N) 2 I x - B^a]2>M ISLAX Pr*ctCmst (USS million) 257.5 321. 125 Creft Amo (USS milion) 129.0 129.0 100 Apdvde 3/29n7 Date of Effectivenes 71f79 3/31179 Dt Physical Compnnt Complted 6130/84 6W30R6 Closig Dam 7/31/85 6/30)86 Etconic Raft of Retmn (%) 36* 36%+ 100+ (see Ov.view, pam 12) Insdtiob Prfonnmoie t y A _ain SPerfonnmSa No of dhct benficirs 340,000 Fscal 79/80 80181 81/82 82/83 83/84 84/85 85J86 8SW87 Appraisal Estimae 3.50 22.00 48.00 76.00 104.00 125.00 129.00 - (USS million) .4 Actud USS Million 7.80 21.40 40.70 S2.40 80.20 10120 11885 129.00 Acnlias of%of EsL 228.57 97.27 84.79 6895 77.12 80.96 92.13 100.00 Dae of Fual Dibusemet August S. 1986 h1mLDOtea Dae No. of Mandas Specia/ aiou Minio Ma-/Xr Eonn inkfiidd R1a3d & l hII amd/ Supv. 1 4)?-5/3279 2 6 EJ"WM 2 1 OM Supv. 2 2/80 2 4 I/WM.E 2 2 OMT Supv. 3 11/80 1 3 I,WM 2 2 OM Supv.4 4/81 1 3 nla nla n/a tla Supv. 5 6R1 2 tO IA 2 2 OMPT Supv. 6 1/82 4 20 1(2).PEF 2 2 FMO Supv. 7 7/82 4 1(2)PEYF 2 2 FM Supv. 8 12/82 2 6 I.PE 2 2 FM Supv. 9 5483 4 16 1 (2),PE.CONS 2 1 F Supv. 10 12183 3 3 (2). CONS 2 1 FO Supv. 11 8/84 2 4 1(2) 2 1 F Supv. 12 3/85 2 10 I,CONS 2 1 F Supv. 13 10/8S 4 20 via I n/a n/a Supv. 14 8/86 ana n/a n/a I nWa n/a (Four minoma supervision missions visited the Sate duing project executon to fWllow up on specific echnil issues) aI I = Iigation Engineer F = Fmancial Analyst E = Ecaomist; PE a Procurement Engineerw WM-Water Mnagement Specialit; CONS - Consulant k/ I - Poblem free or minor problems 2 = modeme probkms; 3 = major problems ,t I z improving, 2 stationary; 3 -detdrioatng 4! F - fincial M - mangmia; Ta tecnical; P -political. 0-ode STAFF INFUTS 76 79 sO il 62 63 64 65 6 7 6a TOTA oCt