Response to P. Braveman et al. [letter]

   
         
  

    
             !! 



" ## $   %%  " & "       "     '          (   ""     )    !!    *

       +,,,  
       

 " '  ! ## $  

 

   %% '       $     '  (!         "

" &                  !     

 !         '- "
                !   "

  $      ."    !  -"     ##  '   $     !    $ %%

                    $         !!    /  '       ! (         $    0     "!    !           !!   !  $    

""-   "      "  - "  !   !     " !              " & "      '"   "      !    ' ""                 ! ( 

 " ""           !       

   !  "          

1 ""  "       ## $   %%   '  !  ##   "%%   "  "          

   '     !        "        $     !   "  !     "       " 0        !                   

 "        2 "   $       ! ." "       " -"     !  ! "  ' ""   ."      - "    '      3  " !  "   "             !         / '       ! "      ! " $      4 0       

-  '      !   

 !      " 5 6'   '          - !   !     '     (     !      5 74 7!"  '  '    ' ! "          ! 5
               (!  "        '    "                      '   " $  4 0     '    '    '  5 )   ""    "       '   (     $    8! " "

'     !       !"   !    (!  "       " / '     '    !     ! (   0        '    !  ##   "%%            -    )    "        " & "    '! "       !    !    

     !   "    !    

9     !       "       !          ! '       / "  :      "            0 " '                   !    "       '     "  '    -       '    "  !  !     ! "   !  '   / ' '         " '     "     ;                     

  $    7" '"      !  !

!  ( !     (  "    

   '          "      "             !    ! ( !  

      !    7     !  !        

       '  (!-  "         2 "

  $       ."    9             !   (    )         !      !   '  !  !  !    ) !   "    '     $ 

" &             " 

   !"     !  " '  

      )

  '    " &   "      "  $     '  "  " &   !    - "   ! ! "      3  ' ( 

"     '    "    "  ! " &  !       /       " &      " &  0         " !  !  " '             -     " &    !  '   )             

   '     " & 4 

 " &        7                  

$    " &   "

      " "     "     " $  "           "

     "      !  !    !    !    "    $         

         
      
    "         "    ! /    $  

'  ! !    ' 

$   !   ! !          $         "   $     (

"        

 " !  - !"       
            $      " "

 '    6'        -

 "         !     ! $   -   !.           ! "   -  '   '     !     ! "    '  

  )  !  !     ! (       

  -  ! !        " 2 !   ' '   

   '          !   !       " '    ! 

      $     0   !      !-      "    !  

  " "    "          !        "  '     !    $     <'    

    !"         ! '  "     

 ' "   "    

"   ' '  
  " (063'   !  2' 
  =! 8  7"  2   (             >    "      $      "    "  "!  "- ! " &     !   -     3 - .   '  

     "      (!    $-       "    :-  !     =     !              ! !       " !

             !

     $       063 " ) !



       "      '"    

!               !    "         063   *     '  !  

 "     "  "     '   "         $    063                "

  "   $      '       ! "   
 !    (  ##     $   %%      '   !       "        ! ! !            ! 

  $  "   "  (    $     0       .             $              ;     063% " ; '     ## $   %%      -

          $      ! "   %


  
               
                        
    ! "#$      %&%#"  '    
  ()     )  ( ) 
*  ()   )  '      
     ) 
*  ()      +      !)      )   *  )    ' !' ,'  ! &' "  #$ %& ''$ (& ) ()

-          . /) ) / 0   ) 1 () 2 3   & . #45%#' 6' %& ''$ "  #$ (& )  " /7    )) - '   ) 1 () 2 3   6 . %65%' #' *+ "  ) 8) /   . ))

-         '  
 
       &' %' , %-)
   .       )    */      ))' +     9   ()   &$ .. 45&' ' " *$ "/ *$ *  -)     )). ) / *      0 9    
  &# . 6&#56#%' $' 0 * %  ) +       "*          7     . ) ! /  
  ' 9           () &: 1. #5%' 4' & $ + /$ )    " ' ,/ ;7 2   


' :' -  & -)            ' 8)  * 7      < &$4 1. #&54#' ' -& #  )$ )     ))' ,/ ;7 2   
 &' &' - '  )        )). ) )   )   '  
)  &% 2. &56%' &&' ' %$ " "$ "  3 ) 1)     ))   ) 0 8)     ))    ' ,/ ;7    = &%' &6' ( *) 8)   )  */        )).   /  )  ' 8)  * 7 < &# 4. 645#66' &#'  5$ , %-$ * *)   

       ))   )     )         ' ,/    9      &4 6&::5&:' &%' "  "%$   "$ '  "-)  >       '  ! / 
*  () &:4 . &&&5&#' &' -  0  ) +    -  

-   ))' ?   8)    2  &:' &$' & 0$ "  $ * #$ 3 + ) 8) 7 !' + . 8/  
 @  , ' + -   )). ) 7 !' ?  
   &::' &4' "  "%)       )) / )   */   ' + . ()   /) @' 9              &% 4 A%B. &456&$' &:' "&7   )    

-   *       / ' 8)  /7       

-   ))' ?  &4 2. &$5&$' &' )        .  "               ' ,/ ;7   ,   &&' 6'  $ ' *$ " ) 8)    /      ) *  /    .      )     *  '   9  
*  () & 2. :$:5:4%' 6&'    ) !          .         ))     /"* '   9  
      &# 2 A$ B. :65&66' 66'  $50 $"  ')     '' *  )) ).   )      '  ! / 
*  () &4 4. #%&5#4:'    
      
 
          6#'  5$ , %-$ *  3) 1)    *) 0 C     )) *)    )  )"    *   )      " '           &4 . :5:&' 6%' -  ))   )) .  1(2>+@

  ' =  1 () 2 3   &$ A * )    1(2> ! >$'&B' 6'  )    -  )).   "   ) /"   "

    ' =  1 () 2 3  &: A * )    1(2>(>(:'&B' ,   )   )
   !! 1!     &       "  $    

      "        &  !  ! ! !  $     

   )       !  ##         $    %%   ##.          $-   %%
   <  ##  %%  1!   ""  0 '  !                

 4     (   0             !  "       !    ! ##   "%%  ##.  "##   $         $         !  ! "  1!   !  !      '   "         "     " &      "               
   ' !   

             !' ! '            (         ? "        (    

           !  '     !' '         !            (       ! ' (   " &    

      "        "   !    "       (    

         1' '    !   !

      1!   4) % ,  ,     , 1!   "  ##""  !   !     " !        

     " & "      '"   "     %% 0 " '   !       ## !    !    "  !    "  (  '    "       

  %%    ##        "

  "  ! !!       !    &%%   0           !  

 !        ##   !    "    !    !   "   "       (      %%  )
     ,   1!   "  ! "  ! !   $   

      ##   "%%   ##          $     !   "  !     "       "%% )  !      0       '        !   $   !    " " )     ! !-

   $   

  

         "      !.      "  $  ! !    " " ) 063%    

    ! !        ! ! "  !-   

      " !   

   

 ) 0 !    1!    !   

!  ##  "  $          '

  "    '   $     !    $   

   %% 
 $  !   "   "          

     $             ' 

!   ! 
  !   !     %

$      " 1!    !   "         

  

    ##  "       '   (     $   %% 0        !    $   

       

'       "    $   '  '   063           '      @(  " ' !  

    "  $ 

 "    '  '   "  !  "  $   

    ) ' 7 !     !    1!     &          ! !   "         )    !    !      !   " "   " '    " "  )   '  !"          !   (   -     $   

   1) 5
8    
    ' 1!   ! 063   " ' !        (    $       " !           7  (!    !   $    

      063 !'  



"   !  !  )"   ! 063 !- "    ! !   "   $   

   )   "      '   "  ! !   $          
#))) "  @  =*
       ()
  1 () 2 3   &6&& =  64 / 3  ')') %&

()
          1 () 2 3   =  / 3  ) (&   @       +    
  1 () 2 3   =  / 3      
      
     (7& ! &' %& ''$ "  #$ (& ) @      )) - .  ) *  )   *   ))  '   ) 1 () 2 3   6 . %65%' 6' "  #$ %& ''$ (& ) ()

-          . /) ) / 0   ) 1 () 2 3   & . #45%#' 1