Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
Republic of Vanuatu
WHO Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data Human resources for health country profiles: Republic of Vanuatu 1. Delivery of healthcare – manpower. 2. Health manpower. 3. Health resources - utilization. I. World Health Organization Regional Office for the Western Pacific. ISBN 978 92 9061 626 9 (NLM Classification: W 76)
© World Health Organization 2013 All rights reserved. Publications of the World Health Organization are available on the WHO web site (www.who.int) or can be purchased from WHO Press, World Health Organization, 20 Avenue Appia, 1211 Geneva 27, Switzerland (tel.: +41 22 791 3264; fax: +41 22 791 4857; e-mail: bookorders@who.int). Requests for permission to reproduce or translate WHO publications –whether for sale or for non-commercial distribution– should be addressed to WHO Press through the WHO web site (www.who.int/about/licensing/ copyright_form/en/index.html). For WHO Western Pacific Regional Publications, request for permission to reproduce should be addressed to Publications Office, World Health Organization, Regional Office for the Western Pacific, P.O. Box 2932, 1000, Manila, Philippines, fax: +632 521 1036, e-mail: publications@wpro.who.int The designations employed and the presentation of the material in this publication do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the World Health Organization concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. Dotted lines on maps represent approximate border lines for which there may not yet be full agreement. The mention of specific companies or of certain manufacturers’ products does not imply that they are endorsed or recommended by the World Health Organization in preference to others of a similar nature that are not mentioned. Errors and omissions excepted, the names of proprietary products are distinguished by initial capital letters. All reasonable precautions have been taken by the World Health Organization to verify the information contained in this publication. However, the published material is being distributed without warranty of any kind, either expressed or implied. The responsibility for the interpretation and use of the material lies with the reader. In no event shall the World Health Organization be liable for damages arising from its use.
Table of contents Acronyms Acknowledgements Executive summary v vi vii 1 1 2 2 3 6 8 8 8 10 10 10 11 11 12 12 12 14 14 17 18 18 18 19 19 19 22 22 23 23 23 25 25 25 26 26 27 28
1. Introduction 1.1 Demographic, social and political background 1.2 Current economic situation and macroeconomic indicators 1.3 Summary of health indicators 1.4 Health system 2. Health workforce supply and trends 3. Health workforce distribution 3.1 Gender distribution 3.2 Age distribution 3.3 Geographical distribution 3.4 Distribution of health workers by urban/rural areas 3.5 Sectoral distribution 3.6 Distribution of health workers by citizenship 3.7 Skills distribution 4. Health professions education 4.1 Medical education 4.2 Nursing education 4.3 Other allied health education 4.4 Educational capacities 4.5 Physical infrastructure 4.6 Technical infrastructure 4.7 Accreditation mechanisms 4.8 In-service and continuing professional education 5. Human resources for health (HRH) utilization 5.1 Recruitment 5.2 Deployment and distribution policies and mechanisms 5.3 Unemployment 5.4 Employment of health workers in the private sector 6. Financing HRH 6.1 HRH expenditure 6.2 Health workers’ remuneration 7. Governance of HRH 7.1 HRH policies and plans 7.2 Policy development, planning and managing for HRH 7.3 Professional regulation 7.4 HRH information systems 7.5 Health workforce requirements 8. Concluding remarks
References 29
Republic of Vanuatu
iii
Annexes Annex A. Ministry of Health organizational chart Annex B. Distribution of public sector health workers by category/cadre and gender, 2012 Annex C. Distribution of public sector health workers by category/cadre and age, 2012 Annex D. Distribution of public sector health workers by category/cadre and by urban/rural areas, 2012
31 31 32 33 34
List of tables Table Table Table Table Table Table Table Table Table Table Table Table Table Table Table Table 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Selected sociodemographic indicators Selected economic indicators Selected health indicators Public health facilities in Vanuatu, 2010 Number of public sector health workers by occupational category/cadre per 1000 population, 2010 and 2012 Distribution of public sector health workers by category/cadre and by region, 2012 Estimated number of private practice health facilities and health workers Distribution of skilled/unskilled health workers, 2012 Number and type of health professions training institutions, by sector, 2012 Number of enrolments by training institution and health profession category, 2008–2012 Number of health professional graduates by training institution and category/cadre, 2008–2011 Average cost of student training, by type of training institution, donor support and number of scholarships, 2012 Number of health professional scholarships by donors, study institutions and category/cadre, 2008–2011 Selected allowances and leave for public health-service staff Average monthly income, by professional category/cadre, 2012 Projected health professional category/cadre workforce needs to maintain 2012 levels in the next 10 and 20 years 1 2 3 5 7 9 11 11 13 15 16 16 17 21 24 27
6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
List of figures Figure 1. Distribution of health workers by gender in selected categories (%), 2012 Figure 2. Distribution of health workers by age in selected categories (%), 2012 Figure 3. Distribution of health workers by selected categories and by urban/rural areas (%), 2012 8 8 10
iv
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
Acronyms AusAID AUT CPE FNU GDP HRD HRH HRMIS JCU JICA MoH NDH NGO NZAID Otago PAU PEI PSC QUT SICHE UPNG US$ VCH VCNE VHTI VUV WHO Australian Agency for International Development Auckland University of Technology (New Zealand) Continuing professional education Fiji National University Gross domestic product Human Resources Development (Ministry of Health) Human Resources for Health Human Resource Management Information System James Cook University (Australia) Japan International Cooperation Agency Ministry of Health Northern District Hospital (Vanuatu) Nongovernmental organization New Zealand Agency for International Development University of Otago, New Zealand Pacific Adventist University (Papua New Guinea) Pacific Eye Institute (Fiji) Public Service Commission Queensland University of Technology (Australia) Solomon Islands College of Higher Education University of Papua New Guinea United States dollar Vila Central Hospital (Vanuatu) Vanuatu College of Nursing Education Vanuatu Health Training Institute Vanuatu Vatu World Health Organization
Republic of Vanuatu
v
Acknowledgements The Vanuatu Human Resources for Health Country Profile was developed by a team comprising Maturine Tary (Director General), Katimal Kaun (Officer-in-Charge, Human Resources Development Unit), and Liency Ala (Acting Manager, Human Resource Management Unit) from the Ministry of Health of the Republic of Vanuatu; and Richard Taylor (Director), Graham Roberts (Deputy Director), and Sophia Lin (Research Officer) of the Human Resources for Health Knowledge Hub1 at the University of New South Wales (UNSW), Australia. The Human Resources for Health country profiles in the Western Pacific Region are prepared under the logistical and editorial support of WHO Western Pacific Regional Office Human Resources for Health Unit and coordinated by a team composed of Gulin Gedik, Ezekiel Nukuro, Rodel Nodora, Rufina Latu, Jose Aguín and Dyann Severo.
1
The Human Resources for Health Knowledge Hub was funded through a grant from the Australian Agency for International Development (AusAID) under the Strategic Partnerships Initiative.
vi
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
Executive summary Background Vanuatu’s population of 245 619 (2011) (World Bank, 2012) live mostly in rural areas, dispersed across 83 islands. There are two urban centres, the capital, Port Vila, with a population of 44 039 (2009), and Luganville with 13 156 people (National Statistics Office, 2010). The country is divided into six provinces, Torba, Sanma, Penama, Malampa, Shefa and Tafea. The population is very young with almost 40% under 15 years of age. External migration is low but movement from rural to urban areas is increasing. Access to health services is difficult for many ni-Vanuatu (name generally given to nationals and citizens of Vanuatu) due to the wide dispersion of the population. An estimated 20% of the population have no access to health services. The Vanuatu economy is driven by exports of copra, timber, beef and cocoa (20% of gross domestic product – GDP), tourism (20%) and foreign aid contributions, with the biggest donors being Australia, France, New Zealand and the United Kingdom. However, it is not expected that these sources of revenue will be sustainable in the future. As external migration is minimal, remittances flowing into the country make up only a small portion of GDP. The lack of economic growth is a major obstacle to the country achieving its health goals. Health indicators are improving, with life expectancy increasing and child mortality rates decreasing. However, noncommunicable diseases are on the rise, contributing to an increase in mortality and morbidity. This is in addition to the burden of communicable diseases, which has not yet been controlled. The Ministry of Health (MoH) is responsible for the delivery of health services, with the Office of the Director General acting as a bridge between the Ministry of Health and the Public Service Commission (PSC). Health services are centralized with a referral system that is funded mostly by general taxation, user fees and donor sources. There are a total of 361 health facilities including two tertiary referral hospitals in Port Vila and Luganville. Patients requiring services that are not available in the country are sent overseas or are treated by visiting clinical teams.
Current health personnel stock levels and distribution There is no functional human resources information system, which has made it difficult to determine the current health workforce situation. Data for this report were sourced from payroll databases, and from nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) and private health facilities that were contacted directly for health worker information. However, the data acquired and presented in this report are a best estimate and results need to be interpreted with caution. Little is known about the utilization of traditional medicine practitioners in Vanuatu. It is estimated there were 1261 government health workers in April 2012, including 46 medical practitioners, 335 nurses and 62 midwives. There were also 206 village health workers spread across rural Vanuatu in aid posts.
Main human resources for health (HRH) issues The main HRH problem is the severe and critical health worker shortages. Vanuatu has the third lowest health workforce density in the Pacific region, with only Papua New Guinea and the Solomon Islands having fewer health workers per capita. As might be expected, the greatest shortages are in rural areas. An ageing workforce and insufficient production of health workers are the main causes of these shortages, rather than migration or resignations. It is estimated that 40 health workers are retiring each year, half of whom are nurses, and there are not enough graduates to replace them. The nursing workforce faces the most severe shortages. It is thought that for every two nurses who retire, only one is replaced. There is a shortage of local specialist skills and foreign workers fill many of the specialist posts. There is limited capacity at both health personnel training centres – the Vanuatu College of Nursing Education (VCNE) in Port Vila and the Vanuatu Health Training Institute (VHTI) in Luganville. A lack of classroom space and supervisors in the hospitals limits yearly intake of pre-service nursing students to 30 per year, and post-basic nursing students to 18 per year. Other health workers are trained overseas, mostly in Cuba, Fiji, or Papua New Guinea. However, Republic of Vanuatu vii
the graduation rate is low with many students failing to complete their course. H u m a n re s o u rc e m a n a g e m e n t n e e d s t o b e strengthened at all levels of the system, starting with the development of an effective human resource information system to facilitate good policy development. Strategic health plans and health workforce development plans have not been fully implemented. Other areas in need of strengthening include: • standardization of employment conditions; • recruitment and promotion of staff based on qualifications and merit; • improvement of salary scales and other remuneration, both fiscal and non-fiscal; • development of systematic supervision systems and support mechanisms; and
• improvement of incentives for rural health workers. Vanuatu’s health workforce presents a paradox – not only are there not enough graduates being produced to fill the severe shortage gaps, but there is also not enough funding to absorb more health workers into the system. At the time of writing, the MoH is attempting to ratify legislation introducing a new governance structure that would create 1983 new permanent posts. To reach this figure, some health workers would be confirmed in posts that they currently occupy, and new health workers would be recruited. In addition, salary scales would be reviewed with a proposal to increase the remuneration of many workers. However, the Ministry of Finance has not yet approved funding for this new structure.
viii
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
1. Introduction 1.1 Demographic, social and political background Demography and geography Vanuatu is an archipelago of 83 islands in the South Pacific Ocean. It is a mostly mountainous country of volcanic origin with narrow coastal plains. The population of 245 619 (2011) (World Bank, 2012) is widely dispersed, with over 80% of the population living on over 70 islands, mostly in rural areas. The capital, Port Vila, is on the island of Efate and is the larger of the two urban centres, with 44 039 (2009) people. Luganville, on the island of Espiritu Santo (Santo), is the other urban centre with a population of 13 156 (2009) (National Statistics Office, 2010). Population growth has fallen in recent years but still remains one of the highest in the Pacific region (ADB, 2009). The country is divided into six provinces – Malampa, Penama, Sanma, Shefa, Tafea and Torba (WHO, 2012) (see Table 1). Locals are predominantly of Melanesian origin with over 105 local dialects. Bislama (pidgin) is the lingua franca, with English and French also official languages. As a result, the government and the society of Vanuatu tends to be divided along linguistic lines. In the 2009 census, 64% of the population stated they had English language abilities, 74% had Bislama, 37% had French, and half the population had other local languages (National Statistics Office, 2010). Table 1. Selected sociodemographic indicators Indicator Year
Over 82% of the population are Christian, with the largest denominations being Anglican, Presbyterian and Roman Catholic. The population is very young, with approximately 40% under 15 years of age (WHO, 2012). Social environment In comparison to other regional counterparts, external migration from Vanuatu is minimal. Migration is mostly internal, from rural to urban centres, as people look for better employment and educational opportunities (WHO, 2012). High internal migration is placing pressure on housing, infrastructure and essential services (ADB, 2009). Access to services can be very difficult due to population dispersion and it is estimated that 20% of the population do not have access to health-care services. A large proportion of people need to travel by boat, canoe or truck to reach the nearest aid post and in some cases, travel can take up to two days (Government of Vanuatu, 2011a). Political environment The islands currently known as Vanuatu were originally named the New Hebrides by British explorer Captain James Cook in 1774. This name lasted until independence (1980). The 18th century saw a rapid increase in trade, with plantations of cotton, coffee, cocoa, bananas and coconuts established. These
Total population Urban population (%) Mortality rate, under five (per 1000 live births) Mortality rate, infant (per 1000 live births) Mortality rate, neonatal (per 1000 live births) Maternal mortality ratio (per 100 000 live births) Births attended by skilled health staff (% of total) 15–64 years (% of total population) 65+ years (% of total population) Total fertility rate (TFR) (estimated births per woman) Crude birth rate (CBR) (per 1000 population) Crude death rate (CDR) (per 1000 population) Literacy rate, adult total (% of adults over 15 years old who read and write) Sources: a World Bank, 2012. b Secretariat of the Pacific Community, 2011.
245 619 24.9 13.9 12.0 7.0 110.0 74.0 57.08 4.05 3.87 29.52 4.83 82.03
2011a 2011b 2010 2010 2010 2010 2007 2009a 2009a 2010a 2010a 2010a 2009a
Republic of Vanuatu
1
plantations increased the number of expatriates settling on the islands. British subjects from Australia settled on the islands and were joined by French nationals after the establishment of the Caledonian Company of the New Hebrides in 1882. In 1906, France and the United Kingdom signed a BritishFrench Condominium to govern the islands jointly. Challenges to this type of rule began in the early 1940s with the first political party, the New Hebrides National Party founded by Father Walter Lini, established in the early 1970s. The party pushed for independence which was finally granted in 1980. The unicameral Vanuatu Parliament is made up of 52 members who are elected every four years by popular vote. These parliamentarians vote for the Prime Minister, who is the head of the government, and requires a minimum three-quarters majority of 39 votes to win. The Prime Minister appoints the Council of Ministers and together they make up the Executive Government. The President is elected for a 5-year term by a two-thirds majority in the Electoral College, which is made up of Members of Parliament and the presidents of regional councils. The President has little administrative power and performs a largely ceremonial role (WHO, 2012). The national Council of Chiefs, known as the Malvatu Mauri, is elected by district councils of chiefs and advises the government on ni-Vanuatu culture and language matters. While Vanuatu has had many no confidence votes passed in Parliament in the past three decades since independence, there have been no major outbreaks of violence associated with leadership changes, unlike in neighbouring Solomon Islands or Papua New Guinea (WHO, 2012).
1.2 Current economic situation and macroeconomic indicators The Vanuatu economy is largely based on agriculture, with approximately 80% of the population engaged in subsistence farming or farming cash crops. Copra is the leading cash crop, followed by timber, beef and cocoa. Exports of these goods currently make up 20% of GDP but this is unlikely to sustain future growth, with the country moving towards increasing revenue from tourism. Tourism currently contributes to 20% of GDP but is not seen as being sustainable for economic growth as the country is susceptible to many natural disasters including earthquakes, volcanic eruptions and cyclones. There are few new jobs created across all sectors of the economy, but cocoa could become an important export if high volumes could be produced (WHO, 2012) (Table 2). Foreign aid contributes greatly to the Vanuatu economy. Since 1980, Australia, France, New Zealand and the United Kingdom have been the largest donors as these countries have strong social and cultural ties to the country. In comparison to other Pacific Island countries, the amount of remittances is small due to the low level of external migration. Remittances amounted to US$ 5 million in 2007, whilst neighbouring country remittances for the same year totalled US$ 165 million (Fiji) and US$ 20 million (Solomon Islands) (UNDP, 2010).
1.3 Summary of health indicators Mortality and life expectancy Health indicators have improved in recent years due to better prenatal care, increased prevalence of
Table 2. Selected economic indicators Indicator Year
GDP , current (US$)
819 227 088 3 335.4 4.3 5.3 157.3 5.3 5.2 4.6 70.6
2011 2011 2011 2010 2010 2010 2009 2009 2010
GDP per capita (current US$) GDP growth (annual %) Health expenditure, total (% of GDP) Health expenditure per capita (current US$) Out-of-pocket health expenditure (% of total expenditure on health) Public spending on education (% of GDP) Unemployment rate (%) Labour participation rate (%) Source: World Bank, 2012.
2
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
Table 3. Selected health indicators Indicator Year
Overall average life expectancy (years) Female average life expectancy (years) Male average life expectancy (years)
70.9 72.9 68.9 13.9 12.0 7.0 110.0 74.0 2010 2010 2010 2010 2007 2010
Mortality rate, under-five (per 1000 live births) Mortality rate, infant (per 1000 live births) Mortality rate, neonatal (per 1000 live births) Maternal mortality ratio (per 100 000 live births) Births attended by skilled health staff (% of total) Source: World Bank, 2012.
skilled health workers attending births, increased immunization, better access to sanitation and more preventive health programmes (ADB, 2009). Improved health services have increased life expectancy. A child born in 2010 can expect to live to 71 years, compared to 62 in 1986. Child health indicators have also improved immensely in the years since independence. Infant mortality rates have decreased fourfold from 47.4 deaths per 1000 live births to 12 in 2010. In the same time period, under-five deaths have decreased from 61.6 to 13.9 per 1000 live births. Neonatal mortality has more than halved, from 16 per 1000 live births in 1990 to seven in 2010 (World Bank, 2012) (Table 3). Vanuatu is on track to meet two of the Millennium Development Goals: Goal 4 (Reduce child mortality) and Goal 6 (Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases). It is off-track to meet the other healthrelated MDG: Goal 5 (Improve maternal health) (Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat, 2011). Main causes of mortality and morbidity Communicable and infectious diseases have traditionally made up a large proportion of deaths and morbidity. However, rates of noncommunicable diseases are increasing due to dietary changes, increased alcohol consumption, rural to urban migration and foreign influences. Incidences of chronic disease are increasing and are expected to accelerate as the elderly and urban populations grow (ADB, 2009; WHO, 2012). In 2009, six of the top 10 causes of mortality were related to noncommunicable diseases—stroke, renal failure, cardiac arrest, cancer, heart failure and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (Government of Vanuatu, 2011a). Increasing urbanization has led to informal settlements in periurban areas that have poor sanitation and living conditions. Waterborne and infectious diseases are a problem in these high-density urban areas and rural regions. At the same time, the relatively high birth
rate means demand for maternal and child services will continue to grow (ADB, 2009).
1.4 Health system Governance structure The Ministry of Health (MoH) is responsible for the delivery of health services in Vanuatu. It develops health policies, coordinates development and planning of the public health sector, and regulates health standards (WHO, 2012). The delivery of health services is driven by the Health Sector Strategy 2010–2016. Since independence in 1980, there has been no approved MoH governance structure. As a result, health governance has been developed on an ad hoc basis. Reform in the health sector began in 2007 with the MoH’s petition to the Public Service Commission (PSC) to validate almost 4000 established posts. It was estimated that each health centre should be staffed by at least one nurse practitioner, one registered nurse, one midwife, one nurse aide and a handyman. This petition was rejected by the PSC and a new structure with 2178 posts was approved in January 2012. However, this structure has yet to be implemented, as extra funding will be needed to pay for staff to move from acting in posts to permanent positions, increases in salaries and for the recruitment of new staff. It had been envisaged that the new structure would be introduced in two phases. Phase 1 would focus on the recruitment of executive and senior managers, support staff and administrative workers. Phase 2 would include the recruitment of medical, nursing and allied health workers, and be based on a salaries review. The PSC asked the MoH to conduct an independent remuneration review before implementation of the new structure. This review has not yet been conducted, and the MoH has asked the Republic of Vanuatu 3
World Health Organization (WHO) and the Australian Agency for International Development (AusAID) for technical assistance, the terms of which are currently being negotiated. The Director General heads the Ministry of Health and advises the Minister for Health and the Public Service Commission. This post is responsible for directing the management of health-service delivery through other MoH directors. There are six units under the Office of the Director General (ODG). These are: • Executive Officer; • Postgraduate Medical Council, Vanuatu Centre for Nursing Education, Vanuatu Health Training Institute, Nursing Council and Central Medical Store; • Corporate services and planning: -- Human resources management and development -- Finance and accounts -- Projects and donor coordination -- Assets and infrastructure -- Internal Auditor -- Health Planner -- IT Officer; • Directorate of Southern Health Care (Shefa and Tafea provinces’ health services); • Directorate of Northern Health Care (Malampa, Sanma, Torba, Penama provinces’ health services); and • Directorate of Public Health (see Annex A) (WHO, 2012). Health services organization Health services are centralized, with a referral pathway focusing on cure rather than prevention (Ministry of Health, 2010a). There are a total of 360 public health facilities consisting of two referral hospitals, three provincial hospitals, 27 health centres, 97 dispensaries and 231 aid posts. The hospitals provide inpatient and specialist services including surgical, obstetric and paediatric care. The two hospitals in urban areas, Vila Central Hospital (VCH) in Port Vila and Northern District Hospital (NDH) in Luganville, are tertiary referral facilities (Table 4). Patients requiring specialized tertiary services not available in the country are sent offshore for treatment (WHO, 2012). The New Zealand Agency for International Development (NZAID) is funding a medical treatment programme that provides treatment to patients with life-threatening or seriously debilitating medical conditions who have a good five-year prognosis. Treatment is provided in Australia, Fiji, New Zealand or other regional countries. The programme covers the cost of treatment from arrival to departure and 4 Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
all support costs (Maoate, Jensen & Sorensen, 2011). Alternatively, visiting clinical teams provide some specialist services. In 2010, there were nine such teams from the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons (SSCSIP, 2011). Health centres and dispensaries are regulated under the Health Committee Act and managed by local communities. There are approximately four health centres and dispensaries in each province providing outpatient and inpatient health-care services, and health promotion and preventive health services such as immunization. Each health centre is managed by a nurse practitioner, and staffed with a midwife and a registered nurse. They are responsible for supervising dispensaries and aid posts in their catchment area. The dispensaries are staffed by registered nurses and nurse aides, and provide primary health care and preventive health services. Each island has at least one aid post providing first aid and community health education which are the responsibility of local governments or church groups (Ministry of Health, 2003). They are staffed by village health workers who receive up to three months basic training in primary and preventive care (Ministry of Health, 2010a). Village health workers are not considered to be MoH staff and thus their services are generally unremunerated. Only one province (Shefa) pays salaries to village health workers. Otherwise, their local communities support them. The small private health sector in the country is located in urban areas. There is a single private hospital, Vila Bay Hospital, located in Port Vila. It has three beds and offers tertiary and secondary care with both inpatient and outpatient services (Ministry of Health, 2003). It is estimated there are another 16 private health facilities, including medical centres, pharmacies and dental clinics. Mostly run by expatriates, these facilities serve the expatriate community and high-income earners who are able to afford their services. There is also a private air ambulance service that provides helicopter transport for medical emergencies in the outer islands, and support for non-critical overseas medical evacuations (ProMedical, 2012). Traditional health workers form part of the health workforce, although the exact number and their specialization is unknown. Anecdotal evidence suggests patients with mild illnesses consult traditional medicine practitioners before turning to conventional practitioners. In serious cases, patients sometimes seek treatment from both traditional and conventional health practitioners (Ministry of Health, 2003).
Table 4. Public health facilities in Vanuatu, 2010 Facilities
Malampa 0 1 9 18 44 72
Penama 0 1 6 22 38 67
Sanma
Shefa
Tafea
Torba
Total 2 3 27 97
Referral hospitals
1 0 6 21 49 77
Provincial hospitals Health centres Dispensaries Aid posts Total
1 0 3 17 35 56
0 1 1 13 46 61
0 0 2 6 19 27
231 360
Source: Office of Human Resource Development Training, 2010.
The Vanuatu Association of Non-Government Organisations oversees the operation of most NGOs in the country (Ministry of Health, 2003). There are approximately four NGO clinics employing six staff across the country. Sources of funding The health system is financed mostly by general taxes and supplemented by user fees and donor sources (Ministry of Health, 2010b). In 2007, the MoH received US$ 10 252 5001 in donor funds, 63% of which was directed to the provinces (ADB, 2009). Until 2005, almost all health services (100% of inpatient and 60% of outpatient) were provided free of charge. Private household contributions were mostly for payments to traditional healers and to some government outpatient facilities. Between 2002 and 2005, these outpatient services generated approximately 95 000–114 000 Vanuatu Vatu (VUV) each year, making up between 1% and 2% of the MoH’s budget. However, this revenue was designated as state revenue and allocated to the Ministry of Finance (WHO, 2012). Prior to 2005, cost-free services resulted in hospital outpatient centres being overburdened as people attended for minor illnesses. Since then, all health facilities and aid posts have charged user fees for all services (AusAID, 2009a; Government of Vanuatu, 2011a), with exemptions for the chronically ill, people on very low incomes, and those with specific medical conditions (Ministry of Health, 2003). The ‘contribution
fee’ at the two tertiary hospitals is currently VUV 200. Nevertheless, this fee, as well as the cost of transport from the outer islands, can still be prohibitive for many people (ADB, 2009). The introduction of small user fees has led many patients to seek treatment at health centres or dispensaries instead as they are cheaper. This has helped reduced the burden on outpatient centres (Ministry of Health, 2003). Private health insurance coverage, which is mostly taken out by expatriates, is on the increase. In 2005, private insurance companies covered 3% of total health expenditure (WHO, 2012). Health expenditure The dispersion of the small population means there is a high unit cost of providing basic primary health care (ADB, 2009). Total health expenditure in 2010 totalled US$ 36 167 504 (5.3% of GDP), or US$ 157.34 per capita (World Bank, 2012). Health services expenditure is not equitable (AusAID, 2009a; Ministry of Health, 2003). In 2003, it was reported that hospital funding accounted for more than 50% of the budget (with Vila Central Hospital accounting for 25% alone), and community health services 23%. Almost half of all government health expenditure focused on inpatient care, compared to 22% on outpatient services and 7% for prevention (Ministry of Health, 2003).
1
US$ 1.00 = VUV 90.5 (1 June 2013).
Republic of Vanuatu
5
2. Health workforce supply and trends 2.1 Current supply of health workers The lack of a functional human resources for health (HRH) database makes it difficult to determine the exact number of health workers in Vanuatu. As a result, public sector health workforce data have been estimated using the Ministry of Finance payroll lists. It has not been possible to identify the number of vacancies in the public sector. On one hand, the country currently does not have enough health workers to adequately serve the population and, on the other hand, the health sector budget cannot support the creation of more posts. Further details on vacancies and the paradox of health workers’ unemployment can be found in Section V (Human resources for health utilization). In April 2012, it was estimated that there were 1261 health workers in the public sector, including 443 doctors, nurses and midwives. This is equal to 1.77 health workers per 1000 population, which is below the WHO recommended 2.3 health workers per 1000 population needed to support the achievement of the Millennium Development Goals (WHO, 2006). Nursing personnel made up the largest cadre of the health workforce at 31.4%, which includes 56 advanced practice nurses and 62 midwives. There are more specialists than generalists in Vanuatu. Of the 46 medical practitioners, 29 are specialists, including eight surgeons, five obstetricians/gynaecologists, four anaesthetists, three paediatricians (one of whom is also an obstetrician/gynaecologist), two internists and one pathologist. The specialities of six doctors are unknown (Table 5). The proportion of paramedical health workers is small, totalling 162 (12.8%). They are mostly medical and pathology laboratory technicians (for the most part microscopists) (4.7%), environmental and occupational health and hygiene professionals (2.9%), pharmaceutical workers (2.3%), dental practitioners (1.4%), and medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians (1.0%) (Ministry of Health, 2011b). It is common to find many health workers employed in two health care positions. Some take on multiple roles within the public service, e.g. doctors working as clinical care providers, while supervising junior staff, facilitating on-the-job training, and participating in programme coordination; or midwives providing clinical maternity services while fulfilling the role of clinical tutor, trainer and supervisor. It should be noted that data from payroll lists were duplicated and included retired health workers. As such, these health workers were eliminated from the health worker count. In cases where a health worker had dual roles, their highest qualifying role was counted.
6
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
Table 5. Number of public sector health workers by occupational category/cadre per 1000 population, 2010 and 2012
2010 Health professional groups/cadre Total HW/1000 population (Pop. 239 631) Total
2012 HW/1000 population (Pop. 251 661)
Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Graduate/registered/professional nurses Midwives Nurse aides/nurse assistants Dentists Dental technicians and assistants Pharmacists Pharmaceutical technicians and assistants Medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Physiotherapists Nutritionists and dieticians Biomedical engineers Medical and dental prosthetic technicians Environmental and occupational health and hygiene professionals Health associate professionals not elsewhere specified Non-health professionals not elsewhere classified Non-health technicians and associate professionals not elsewhere classified Health service managers Health management personnel not elsewhere classified Community health workers Traditional and complementary medicine associate professionals Personal care workers in health services not elsewhere classified Service and sales workers Clerical support workers Domestic and ancillary support workers Total Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
32 45 244 51 85 5 6 4 11 9 20 5 1 ND ND ND 21 ND ND ND ND 212 ND ND ND 27 111 889
0.13 0.19 1.02 0.21 0.35 0.02 0.03 0.02 0.05 0.04 0.08 0.02 0.0 ND ND ND 0.09 ND ND ND ND 0.88 ND ND ND 0.11 0.46 3.71
17 29 56 279 62 152 7 10 6 23 12 59 3 2 2 2 36 17 53 5 9 31 206 2 8 13 29 131 1261
0.07 0.12 0.22 1.11 0.25 0.60 0.03 0.04 0.02 0.09 0.05 0.23 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.14 0.07 0.21 0.02 0.04 0.12 0.82 0.01 0.03 0.05 0.12 0.52 5.02
Republic of Vanuatu
7
3. Health workforce distribution 3.1 Gender distribution Women comprise almost half the health workforce due to the largely female nursing cadre. However, there are fewer women in highly skilled positions (e.g. only 38% of general practitioners and 27% of specialist practitioners are female), or in health management posts (38%) (see Figure 1 below and Annex B). needs for the future. Data show that a total of 373 health workers do not have their ages recorded (29.5%), the majority of whom are community health workers (none of the 206 has their age recorded). Setting this category aside, there are still 167 health workers whose ages are unknown (15.8%). It should be noted that many of the health workers without a recorded age are expatriates. The retirement age in Vanuatu is 55 years, but this is not strictly enforced as the Public Service Commission and the Ministry of Health are not able to pay severance entitlements. It is estimated that approximately 40 health workers retire each year,
3.2 Age distribution The age of a significant proportion of the health workforce is not recorded on payroll sheets, which makes it difficult to accurately project workforce
Figure 1. Distribution of health workers by gender in selected categories (%), 2012 Midwives Graduate/registered/professional nurses Domestic and ancillary support workers Community health workers Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Medical and pathology laboratory technicians 0% ND, not determined. Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
6 37 47 43 38 27 26 25 53 57 62 73 74 75 63
94
Male Female
10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
Figure 2. Distribution of health workers by age in selected categories (%), 2012 60% 52
<30 Yrs 30–39 38 31 24 13 13 6 0 0 14 30 26 18 10 8 3 0 41 36 37 31 23 19 22 23 17 13 2 36 30 28 39
50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0%
40–49 50–59 >60
6
9 1
Generalist medical practitioners
Specialist medical practitioners
Advanced practice nurses
Graduate/ registered/ professional nurses
Midwives
Domestic and ancillary support workers
Medical and pathology laboratory technicians
Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
8
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
including approximately 20 nurses (Ministry of Health, 2011b). Currently, there are 102 health workers who have reached retirement age. Discounting the community health workers, if the government enforced the retirement age, and the health workers whose ages are unknown were to retire, up to 30.0% (n=317) of the current health workforce would retire within the next decade, including 1.6% (n=17) of
doctors, 13.1% (n=138) of nurses and 3.6% (n=38) of midwives. Categories such as general medical doctors are relatively young, with 38% of this category under the 30 years old. Other categories, like midwives and domestic and ancillary support workers, have more than a third of their members in the 40–49 years old age group. (see Figure 2 and Annex C).
Table 6. Distribution of public sector health workers by category/cadre and by region, 2012 HW*/1000 population Health professional group/cadre Shefa Tafea Total Malampa Penama Sanma (pop. (pop. (pop. (pop. (pop. 38 187) 32 323) 49 411) 88 082) 33 733) Torba (pop. 9925)
Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Graduate/registered/ professional nurses Midwives Nurse aides/nurse assistants Dentists Dental technicians and assistants Pharmacists Pharmaceutical technicians and assistants Medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Physiotherapists Nutritionists and dieticians Biomedical engineers Medical and dental prosthetic technicians Environmental and occupational health and hygiene professionals Health associate professionals not elsewhere specified Non-health professionals not elsewhere classified Non-health technicians and associate professionals not elsewhere classified Health service managers Health management personnel not elsewhere classified Community health workers Traditional and complementary medicine associate professionals Personal care workers in health services not elsewhere classified Service and sales workers Clerical support workers Domestic and ancillary support workers Total * HW, health worker. Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
17 29 56 279 62 152 7 10 6 23 12 59 3 2 2 2 36 17 53 5 9 31 206 2 8 13 29 131 1261
0.03 0.03 0.26 0.81 0.21 0.68 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.03 0.03 0.24 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.03 0.03 0.00 0.00 0.03 0.05 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.03 0.03 0.24 3.72
0.00 0.00 0.22 0.99 0.15 0.59 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.19 0.03 0.31 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.06 0.12 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.15 0.96 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.06 0.40 4.33
0.14 0.10 0.32 1.40 0.36 0.79 0.04 0.08 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.22 0.02 0.02 0.00 0.00 0.06 0.08 0.08 0.02 0.00 0.10 1.01 0.00 0.06 0.02 0.16 0.65 5.93
0.08 0.26 0.12 1.19 0.23 0.34 0.06 0.07 0.03 0.11 0.06 0.25 0.02 0.01 0.02 0.02 0.15 0.02 0.49 0.03 0.08 0.20 0.43 0.02 0.05 0.12 0.17 0.67 5.32
0.06 0.00 0.21 0.92 0.21 0.83 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.09 0.03 0.06 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.42 0.09 0.12 0.00 0.00 0.03 0.80 0.00 0.03 0.00 0.06 0.44 4.39
0.00 0.00 0.50 1.11 0.40 1.01 0.00 0.00 0.10 0.00 0.00 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.30 0.30 0.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.22 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.10 0.30 6.95
Republic of Vanuatu
9
Figure 3. Distribution of health workers by selected categories and by urban/rural areas (%), 2012 Specialist medical practitioners Generalist medical practitioners Domestic and ancillary support workers Graduate/registered/professional nurses Midwives Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Advanced practice nurses Community health workers 0 0% Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
3 18 37 48 48 36 27 52 53 64 73 63 82
97
Rural Urban
100
10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
3.3 Geographical distribution There is geographical maldistribution of health workers and disparate allocation of skills mix across the country. Torba province has the highest health worker density at 6.95 per 1000 population, but has no doctor and most health services are provided by community health workers. Conversely, Shefa and Sanma provinces have a high health worker density at 5.93 and 5.32 per 1000 population respectively, and wider variety of services due to the two tertiary referral hospitals in Port Vila and Luganville. These provinces also have a greater share of health workers per population. Shefa province has 35% of the population and 37.2% of health workers; Sanma province has 19.6% of the population and 23.2% of the health workers. In comparison, Malampa province has 15.2% of the population, but only 11.3% of the health workers. Despite this, distribution is also not equitable among the provinces with urban areas. Sanma province meets the minimum threshold of doctors, nurses and midwives to assist in the achievement of the Millennium Development Goals (2.3 per 1000 population), compared to Shefa province with 1.9 per 1000 population (Table 6).
ratio of doctors to population in rural areas is 1:47 250 compared to 1:1492 in urban areas (see Figure 3 and Annex D). For this report, it is assumed that the urban health workers are based at Vila Central Hospital or Northern District Hospital, or are listed as being part of planning and administration at the Ministry of Health.
3.5 Sectoral distribution Information on health workers in the private sector (both for- and not-for-profit) is not easily attainable and is derived from contacting the organizations directly. As the characteristics of this workforce are not known, they are not included in tables 5–9 and 11. However, more information on the private sector is documented in Table 10 and Section V (Human resources for health utilization). This includes data from the NGO, Save the Children Australia, which trains village health workers (classified here as community health workers), who make up over 16% of the public health workforce. This is a significant proportion, particularly as they often serve hard-to-reach areas and are unpaid labour. Thus, they are not technically classified as being Ministry of Health staff (Ministry of Health, 2003). An estimated 21 private health facilities (see Table 7), mainly operated by foreigners, serve to the expatriate community or high-income earners. These facilities have approximately 46 staff, including an additional two doctors who have dual practice roles, being employed in the public sector and supplementing their incomes with a part-time private practice. These doctors have not been included in the private sector health worker count. It is unclear if these are all clinical staff, or also include support workers such as administrative staff. It is likely that the private sector is larger than the data
3.4 Distribution of health workers by urban/rural areas The majority of health workers practise in the rural areas of the country. The skills base is low, with all the community health workers in these areas providing most health services. Over half the nursing workforce is found in rural areas, including 73.2% of all advanced practice nurses. However, as approximately 75% of the population live in the rural areas, nursing workloads are high. Here, the ratio of nurses to population is 1:218 compared to 1:179 in urban areas. Similarly, the 10 Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
Table 7. Estimated number of private practice health facilities and health workers Private practice health facility/service Number Total staff
Hospital NGO clinics Medical clinics Dental clinicsa,b Pharmacies Physiotherapy clinic Medical and pathology laboratory Ambulatory care Total Sources: a South Pacific Smiles, 2012. b Vanuatu Tourism Office, 2012.
1 4 6 2 5 1 1 1 21
3–4 6 9 15; including: specialist dental practitioners – 5 general dental practitioners – 5 dental technicians and assistants – 3 practice manager/receptionist – 2 8 1 1 Not known At least 46
presented here, although it is known that the overall sector is small.
3.6 Distribution of health workers by citizenship The exact number of expatriate health workers is not known. There are at least 11 expatriate doctors working in the public sector; five recruited through the Pacific Technical Assistance in Medicine (PacTAM) scheme, five from Cuba and one from Australia. It is also known that 24 nurses were recruited from the Solomon Islands in early 2012. It is probable that there are other expatriates working in the public service, most likely in specialist positions where there is a skills gap in the local workforce. For example, Lenakel
Hospital has not had a paid ni-Vanuatu doctor for the last 10–20 years. However, a local doctor is due to start working in Lenakel (Tafea) and Lolowai (Penama) hospitals in October 2012. Other expatriate health workers are mostly in the private sector, including doctors, dentists and pharmacists.
3.7 Skills distribution For every doctor practising in Vanuatu there are 8.6 nurses, but this varies greatly between urban (1:4.3) and rural (1:54.5) areas, and between provinces (Malampa 1:24.5; Penama and Torba have no doctors) (Table 8).
Table 8. Distribution of skilled/unskilled health workers, 2012 Health worker
Ratio 1:8.6 1:5.97 1:33.6 1:3.7 1:1.3 1:3.6 1:3 1:59
Physicians: Nurse Unskilled: Skilled HRH Private: Public providers by HRH category Medical practitioners Dental practitioners Pharmaceutical personnel Physiotherapists Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
Republic of Vanuatu
11
4. Health professions education There are two formal health personnel (nurse) training schools in Vanuatu. Save the Children Australia trains community health workers on-the-job. All other health personnel training is conducted overseas, mostly in Fiji, Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands, and more recently, in Cuba. The large majority of students are supported through scholarships sponsored by the Vanuatu government or by donor partners (mostly AusAID or NZAID). scholarships. As such they are thus obliged to return to work in their home provincial hospitals. Many ni-Vanuatu students who are not on bonded scholarships do not return to the country to develop their skills after completing their training offshore (WHO, 2004). Returning graduates are placed in a supervised internship with senior specialist doctors and acquire registration locally. Expatriates based at Vila Central Hospital, a teaching hospital for the Fiji National University, usually fill any gaps in specialist disciplines. This has enabled local students to complete their internships in the country, which has improved retention rates (Buchan, 2011). The need to send medical students to many different countries presents its own problems and, as noted by the MoH, the skill level of returning graduates is not uniform. For example, Cuban-trained doctors are not taught to perform caesarean sections (Negin, 2011), and midwives may need to be stationed with them in rural health facilities to offset the gap in their skills. So far, no assessment of the appropriateness of the Cuban medical programme or of any additional training the students may require on return has been made (Buchan, 2011).
4.1 Medical education There is no public medical training school in Vanuatu. Most doctors complete their training at the Fiji National University (FNU) or the University of Papua New Guinea (UPNG). Two groups of students have been sent to Cuba to study medicine on scholarships sponsored by the Cuban government. This scholarship includes full tuition, housing, meals, textbooks, school uniforms, incidentals and a monthly stipend. The government of Vanuatu covers travel to and from Cuba. In 2008, 17 students were sent to the School of Medicine in Granma province ( Facultad de Ciencias Medicas Granma). In 2009, 10 students were sent to the Latin American School of Medicine (Escuela Latinoamericana de Medicina) in Havana. Two students from the latter cohort have already returned home after failing the course. All but one of the other students have completed the course, with one student repeating second year subjects (Tokon, Carlot & Christophe, 2011). The first group of students are due to return in 2014 (AusAID 2009b; Buchan, 2011; Government of Vanuatu, 2011a; Kafoa, 2011; Ministry of Health, 2010a). The Latin American School of Medicine is accredited by WHO and by the Medical Board of California (Tokon, Carlot & Christophe, 2011). The Cuban medical programme, which is in Spanish, takes six years. Ni-Vanuatu students, like all other Pacific Island students, spend a preliminary year learning Spanish and pre-medicine coursework. Each specialty is taught by a practising professor-level academic. Graduates are awarded a doctorate of medicine (MD), and it is expected that they will work as family health doctors in rural areas (Tokon, Carlot & Christophe, 2011). The students who were sent to Cuba are from all six provinces and are on bonded 12 Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
4.2 Nursing education There are two nurse training schools in Vanuatu: the Vanuatu College of Nursing Education (VCNE), based in Port Vila; and the Vanuatu Health Training Institute (VHTI), based in Luganville. The VCNE operates under the Vanuatu Nursing Collect Act and has its own legally binding standards and Code of Practice (Kafoa, 2011). Some nursing students are sent overseas to the Solomon Islands College of Higher Education (SICHE), to the Atoifi Adventist Nursing College (AANC), or the Fiji National University to study. The cost of training for these students is estimated to be approximately VUV 4 million comprising tuition and establishment fees. Students are expected to pay for their own airfares and other allowances (Ministry of Health, 2011b). A policy decision in 2003 to reduce the nursing school’s annual budget obliged the school to adopt alternating yearly intake of students instead of annual intakes, which has contributed to the current
nursing shortfalls. In an effort to address the problem, the government has instigated a 6-month bridging course to prepare more young people for the workforce (Government of Vanuatu, 2011a). The VCNE recommenced annual intakes in 2009. There is a high level of competition to gain entry into the nursing programme. The school’s capacity is limited to 30 places a year. In 2011, there were approximately 500 applicants for these places (Kafoa, 2011; Ministry of Health, 2011a). In 2012, this figure jumped to almost 600. Potential applicants must have passed Year 13 Science to be eligible. A short list is compiled and these applicants undergo an interview and a three-hour written examination. Anecdotally, there is political pressure to circumvent the application process and accept students who lack the ability to complete the nursing programme which reduces the number of nursing graduates. In 2003, the graduate rate was quoted to be 60–80% (Ministry of Health, 2003). This is a significant problem as the nursing workforce shortage is severe and every effort should be made to ensure all enrolled students graduate. Completion of the diploma-level basic course qualifies students as registered nurses and practical placements are completed at the VCH and selected community health services. Upon graduation, nurses are usually placed at the VCH for at least a year to practice under close supervision before being posted elsewhere to provide community health services. Graduates of this programme are only able to register in Vanuatu (Kafoa, 2011; Ministry of Health, 2011a). The course is instructed in Bislama, French and English, but most handouts and all examinations are in English (Ministry of Health, 2003). The course is fully funded by the government and students are given a scholarship for living expenses (Ministry of Health,
2003). The course is competency-based, and includes a competency standards booklet and competency assessment tools. The VHTI was set up in 2009, and the post-basic nursing programmes were moved from the VCNE to VHTI. Initially, these nursing programmes (midwifery and nurse practitioner) were combined to create an 18-month course that produced highly skilled, dualqualified nurses that could be deployed in rural areas. However, this programme was split into two separate, certificate-level, 9-month courses because the Nurses Act (2000) did not allow for nurses to be registered as both midwives and nurse practitioners. Nurses were obliged to choose to register as one or the other. When the original midwifery and nurse practitioner course was held by the VCNE, the courses did not have annual enrolment. Between 1983 and 2003, eight midwifery and seven nurse practitioner courses were held (Ministry of Health, 2003). Since moving the courses to the VHTI, post-basic nursing programmes have been held annually. Annually, the six provincial governments select three registered nurses each, with a minimum of five years’ experience, to start post-basic training. The type of training provided is dependent on the provinces’ needs. For example, in one year a province may choose to send two nurses for nurse practitioner training and one for midwifery, and do the opposite the following year. The courses are run in parallel to each other and the VHTI accepts a total of 18 students (each province sending three nurses). The government supports all the students in these courses and the graduation rate is very high. Between 1983 and 2003, the drop-out rate was under 5% (Ministry of Health, 2003) (Table 9). Nurse aides are trained on-the-job for nine months in Port Vila or Luganville by VCNE tutors, and have
Table 9. Number and type of health professions training institutions, by sector, 2012 Health professional group/cadre Number and type of ownership Public Private Total
Advanced practice nurses Midwives Graduate/registered/ professional nurses Nurse aidesa Community health workers
Vanuatu Health Training Institute Vanuatu College of Nursing Education NA 2
NA NA NA N/A Save the Children Australia 1
1 1 1
Total
3
NA, not applicable. a Nurse aides are trained on-the-job in Port Vila or Luganville by VCNE tutors. Sources: Buchan, 2011; Vanuatu Health Training Institute (personal communication, October 2012); Vanuatu College of Nursing Education (personal communication, October 2012).
Republic of Vanuatu
13
no formal qualifications. Often, these nurse aides complete a portion of a nursing diploma but do not always complete the course. In recent years, the course has been formalized, and 40 students graduated in 2010 and 42 in 2011 (18 in Port Vila, 24 in Santo). All those who enrolled in the nurse aide course passed the final examination, and it is anticipated that this programme will continue for the next five years to 2017.
4.3 Other allied health education All other allied health workers are trained offshore, mostly at Fiji National University, but also at other institutions based on donor funding and scholarships (Ministry of Health, 2003). As mentioned earlier, The Save the Children Australia NGO operates a village health worker training programme for local rural health-care workers (Kafoa, 2011). This eight-week programme is followed by a two-week refresher course. Village health workers are not considered to be Ministry of Health staff (Ministry of Health, 2003). However, it is forecast that if the new governance structure and establishment posts receive budgetary approval, they will become part of MoH staff and receive salaries. Currently, they provide the bulk of primary health care and are supported by their local communities. Shefa Province is the only province that pays their village health workers.
interested) students willing to start health personnel training is very low. Overall, just 5% of the population has completed tertiary education, or has a vocational or professional qualification (National Statistics Office, 2010). However, competition to gain entry into VCNE is high, with just 5% (30/600) of applicants being accepted in 2012. It is likely that most of the 570 rejected applicants were not successful because they did not meet the minimum entry requirements and not because of the space restrictions. In fact, based on the high level of attrition in overseas training institutions, it is likely that secondary school graduates’ abilities are below those of their regional counterparts. Students from rural areas are encouraged to apply for health personnel training in an effort to reduce workforce shortages in these areas. However, as yet, there is no prioritizing of applications from rural students. All students are selected on ability. This can be a disadvantage for students from rural areas, as secondary school education tends to be of poorer quality due to a lack of resources and lower quality teaching. Caution is needed if quotas for rural students were introduced as this could lead to poor quality nurses, or an unnecessary waste of resources if such students were ultimately incapable of finishing the course (Table 10). The management boards of VCNE and VHTI report to the Office of the Director General. Nursing standards and curricula are designed by the boards in conjunction with the Nursing Council (Ministry of Health, 2010c). Nursing competency assessment tools have been developed, and it is anticipated that these tools will be introduced in 2013. Currently, the VCNE does not have sufficient tutors or classroom space to increase nurse training. As mentioned above, the school can only take up to 30 students each year and it is estimated that an extra 4–5 tutors are needed to relieve high teaching loads (Ministry of Health, 2010a). In addition, increasing the production of nurses is only half the solution. There are not enough registered nurses with adequate experience to effectively supervise new graduate nurses without putting patient safety at risk. At present, only VCH is able to provide such supervision (Ministry of Health, 2011b), which means that all students are channelled through one facility, increasing the supervisors’ workload. In addition, the 2011 budget allocation for VCNE was overspent by approximately VUV 3 million, which was mostly due to travel and vehicle maintenance costs.
4.4 Educational capacities Basic education is not compulsory and enrolment rates are the lowest in the Pacific region. The 2009 Housing Census indicated that the national literacy rate was 84.8%, but as the official definition of literacy is completion of four years of formal schooling, the rate of functional literacy is likely to be lower. Only a small proportion of students progress through to year 13 (National Statistics Office, 2010) due to parents questioning the relevance of the curriculum, prohibitive school fees (up to VUV 75 000 per year for secondary school), and a lack of classroom space (Government of Vanuatu, 2005). The quality of education is also low, with approximately 1000 teachers lacking proper teaching qualifications. However, a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) was signed in 2012 between the Ministry of Education and the University of the South Pacific to formally train all these teachers over the next five years (Government of Vanuatu, 2012). At the same time, many teachers have not been paid for at least a full school year, and are working free of charge. Thus, the pool of capable (and 14 Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
Table 10. Number of enrolments by training institution and health profession category, 2008–2012 Health professional category/cadre 2008 2009 Number of entrants 2010 2011 2012
Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Graduate/registered/ professional nurses Midwives Nurse aides/nurse assistants Dentists Pharmacists Physiotherapists Physiotherapy technicians and assistants Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians Environmental and occupational health and hygiene professionals Nutritionists and dieticians Health management personnel Health professionals not elsewhere classified Total
11 (FNU) 17 (Cuba) 3 (FNU) NA NA NA NA 2 (FNU) 3 (FNU) NA NA 1 (FNU) NA 1 (FNU) NA NA 4 (FNU) 42
10 (FNU) 8 (Cuba) 5 (FNU) 1 (VCH) 18 (VHTI)*
19 (FNU) 3 (FNU) NA
13 (FNU) 4 (FNU) 12 (VHTI) 31 (VCNE) 4 (UPNG) 5 (SICHE) 3 (Atoifi) 3 (FNU) 8 (VHTI) 42 (VCNE) 3 (FNU) 1 (UPNG) 3 (FNU) 1 (FNU) NA 4 (FNU) 3 (FNU) 1 (Philippines) NA 1 (FNU) NA 10 (FNU) 152
10 (FNU) 5 (FNU)1 (UPNG) 9 (VHTI) 27 (VCNE) 9 (VHTI) NA 4 (FNU) 2 (FNU) 1 (FNU) NA 7 (FNU) 8 (FNU) NA 3 (FNU) 1 (FNU) 10 (FNU) 1 (Otago) 1 (JCU) 1 (QUT) 100
22 (VCNE) 28 (VCNE) NA NA 3 (FNU) 4 (FNU) NA NA 3 (FNU) NA 1 (FNU) NA NA 5 (FNU) 80 NA 40 (VCNE) 3 (FNU) 1 (UPNG) 4 (FNU) NA 3 (FNU) 4 (FNU) 1 (FNU) NA 1 (FNU) 1 (FNU) 8 (FNU) 116
NA, not applicable. * Students in these classes are also trained in midwifery but they are obliged to enrol for midwifery or nurse practitioner courses due to the lack of provision in the Nurses Act to register for both. Sources: Fiji National University (personal communication, October 2012); Kafoa (2011); Ministry of Health (personal communication, October 2012); Vanuatu Health Training Institute (personal communication, October 2012).
Until the late 1990s, the Ministry of Health had planned pre-service training of nursing personnel based on the training capacity of the VCNE and available funding, rather than on identified healthservice needs (Ministry of Health, 2003). This policy decision meant many people could not access vital health-care services. Medical students in Cuba have requested that allowances provided to them by the Vanuatu government be increased as they progress through the medical programme because of the increasing costs of textbooks, Internet fees, and travel between schools and teaching facilities with each school year. If this request is granted, these costs need to be factored into the health budget. Transfer of funds between
the two countries is also problematic, with delays in processing (Tokon, Carlot & Christophe, 2011). A 2011 mission report recommended that graduates from Cuban universities should complete their two-year internship in provincial hospitals rather than in VCH or NDH. This is likely to be very difficult as there are only four doctors in the provinces with enough suitable experience to adequately supervise young doctors. In addition, posting more doctors to rural areas would require additional funds to support the increased costs of housing, medical equipment, essential medicines and travel. A second recommendation to send approximately 10 students every 1–2 years to Cuba to increase the number of ni-Vanuatu doctors is also likely to be unviable in terms of the financial cost (both direct and indirect), Republic of Vanuatu 15
Table 11. Number of health professional graduates by training institution and category/cadre, 2008–2011 Health professional category/cadre Number of graduates 2008 2009 2010 2011
Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Graduate/registered/professional nurses Midwives Nurse aides/nurse assistants Dentists Pharmacists Pharmaceutical technicians and assistants Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Environmental and occupational health and hygiene professionals Health professionals not elsewhere classified Total
NA 1 (FNU) 2 (PEI) NA NA NA 1 (FNU) 1 (FNU) NA NA 1 (FNU) 4 (FNU) 10
4 (FNU) 2 (FNU) 1 (PEI) NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 4 (FNU) 11
NA 2 (FNU) 1 (PEI) 18 (VHTI)* 21 (VCNE) 5 (SICHE) 1 (FNU) 40 (VCNE) NA NA NA NA NA 1 (FNU) 157
2 (FNU) 1 (FNU) 1 (VCH) 1 (PEI) 12 (VHTI) NA 8 (VHTI) 42 (VCNE) NA NA 1 (FNU) 2 (FNU) NA 2 (FNU) 72
NA, not applicable. * Graduates from these classes are also trained in midwifery but are obliged to register as midwives or as nurse practitioners due to the lack of provision in the Nurses Act to register for both. Sources: Fiji National University (personal communication, October 2012); Ministry of Health (personal communication, October 2012); Pacific Eye Institute (personal communication, October 2012); Vanuatu Health Training Institute (personal communication, October 2012).
Table 12. Average cost of student training, by type of training institution, donor support and number of scholarships, 2012 Type of training institution Average cost of training (US$) Public Private Donor support to training No. of scholarships
Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Midwives Graduate/registered/ professional nurses Dentists Pharmacists Nutritionists and dieticians Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians Health management personnel Health professionals not elsewhere classified Total NA, not applicable. Sources: Buchan, 2011; Ministry of Health, 2012.
NA NA 10 600 per student 1275 per course NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
4 AusAID; 2 NZAID (6 FNU) AusAID (2 FNU, 1 UPNG) MoH (18 VHTI) Vanuatu government (27 VCNE) NZAID (FNU) NZAID (FNU) WHO (FNU) 2 AusAID; 4 NZAID (6 FNU) AusAID (FNU) Vanuatu government (FNU) Vanuatu government (Otago); WHO (JCU); AusAID (OUT)
6 3 18 27 1 1 1 6 1 1 3 68
16
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
Table 13. Number of health professional scholarships by donors, study institutions and category/cadre, 2008–2011 Health professional group/cadre 2008 2009 2010 2011
Generalist medical practitioners
Total 19: 1 AusAID (FNU) 1 NZAID (FNU) 17 Cuba NA NA NA
Total 10: Cuba Total 2: 1 AusAID (VCH) 1 NZAID (FNU) 18 MoH (VHTI)
Total 3: 1 AusAID (FNU) 2 NZAID (FNU) NA NA NA
Total 4: 2 AusAID (FNU) 1 NZAID (FNU) 1 Vanuatu (FNU) 3 AusAID (FNU) 12 MoH (VHTI) 8 MoH (VHTI) Total 43: 31 Vanuatu (VCNE) 8 MoH (5 SICHE, 3 Atoifi) 3 Vanuatu (PAU) 1 AusAIDa (PAU) 1 AusAID (FNU) 1 Vanuatu (UPNG) NA 1 AusAID (FNU) 1 Vanuatu (Philippines) 2 AusAID (FNU) 1 NZAID (FNU) 51.6
Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Midwives
Graduate/registered/ professional nurses
NA
22 Vanuatu (VCNE)
28 Vanuatu (VCNE)
Dentists Pharmacists Physiotherapists Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians Proportion of women (%)
NA NA NA NA NA 31.6
1 NZAID (FNU) 1 AusAID (FNU) 1 NZAID (FNU) NA 1 AusAID (FNU) NA 44.4
1 NZAID (UPNG) NA NA 1 NZAID (FNU) 1 AusAID (FNU) 52.8
NA, not applicable. Source: Buchan, 2011, Training and Scholarships Coordination Unit (personal communication, October 2012), Ministry of Education (personal communication, October 2012).
and the amount of supervision needed (Tokon, Carlot & Christophe, 2011). As demonstrated in Tables 11 and 12, many students who enrol in health personnel training courses do not graduate. However, there is no information available on what happens to these students, or on whether or not they return to Vanuatu. Most students are supported by scholarships. Nursing students who are not supported are charged tuition fees of VUV 20 000 per term, or VUV 40 000 per year. Registered nurses undergoing post-basic training at VHTI do not pay tuition fees and are provided with a living allowance. This in-service training is paid for by the Human Resources Department at the MoH which has a total budget of VUV 18 million per year, or VUV 1 million per student including tuition and living expenses (Table 12). In 2012 alone, 68 scholarships were allocated, 50% of which were given to female students. These
scholarships are registered with the Training and Scholarships Coordination Unit (TSCU) at the Ministry of Education. However, this is less than the reported 100 students enrolled across health training institutions in the region in the same year (Table 10). It is not clear how students without scholarships are able to afford tuition and living expenses, but it is assumed they are supported by private donors or are self-funded. Between 2008 and 2011, AusAID, NZAID and the governments of Cuba and Vanuatu provided most of the scholarships. A summary of the number and source of scholarships, as well as where students are studying, can be found in Table 13.
4.5 Physical infrastructure The VCNE is in the same building complex as the Ministry of Health, a former hospital site. In 2003, it was reported there were two classrooms, a small demonstration room, library, offices and a storage Republic of Vanuatu 17
room. Space is limited and the facilities and equipment require repair or replacement (Ministry of Health, 2003). Currently, an extension of 4–5 new classrooms is being built. There are no dormitories and students are expected to live with their families while they are studying. The VHTI is based at the Northern District Hospital compound and consists of a lecture room and two classrooms. There are no wet laboratories, libraries or other facilities.
4.6 Technical infrastructure The VCNE is situated in the Directorate of Planning and Administration, under the Human Resource Development and Training Unit, and is managed by the Principal Nurse Educator. In 2003, the MoH reported that there were five other tutors including a nurse practitioner, a midwife, three general nurses and one tutor working on the Village Health Worker Training Programme. Five of the staff have a minimum certificate-level qualification in education. Nurse tutors are responsible for the theoretical training and clinical supervision of students during practise (Ministry of Health, 2003). In 2011, it was reported that staffing had increased to 11 teachers, five of whom are locals, giving a staff-to-student ratio of approximately 1:9 (Government of Vanuatu, 2011b). There are currently three staff teaching at the VHTI, one midwife and two nurse practitioners. These nurse educators are not formally trained in education, and although there is a curriculum, they generally teach from experience.
Resource Development Plan 2001 and the Workforce Training Plan 2004–2008. The former was developed to address in-service training needs and was based on a skills audit of MoH staff, and the identification of clinical and non-clinical skills gaps. Following this, a Health Training Committee was formed and tasked with planning in-service training, which is implemented by the Human Resource Development and Training Unit under the MoH. The Workforce Training Plan focused on developing workforce skills that were in greatest demand and prioritizing clinical refresher courses (Ministry of Health, 2004). Annual training plans were also developed. However, this planning has not resulted in significant changes to CPE despite a high demand from health workers. Financial constraints and the ineffectiveness of the Health Training Committee means the planning of the training often falls to the Acting Manager of the Human Resource Development and Training Unit. Training is also not well coordinated, with some public health programmes, including immunization, and maternal and child health, providing vertical in-service training to staff (Ministry of Health, 2003). Most of the funding of pre-service and postgraduate training is borne by the government with a small contribution from donor agencies. A portion of the MoH budget is set aside for the VCNE’s personnel and operating costs, with the government also providing full pay, scholarships and living allowances for nurses undertaking midwifery or nurse practitioner training. Other health workers are given transport allowances to commute from rural to urban areas for training. Changes have been introduced in an effort to reduce the cost of post-service training. Accommodation and meals for student nurses at VCH have been scrapped, and the practice of providing living allowances for midwifery and nurse practitioner students will be discontinued. Fees will be charged to help offset the effects of budget cuts (Ministry of Health, 2003). For the nursing personnel, JICA is supporting the ‘Strengthening the Needs-Based In-Service Training for Community Health Nurses (2011–2014)’ project which aims to improve and strengthen supervision and coaching, and identify training needs at the health centre and dispensary level. In addition, with assistance from the VCNE and Vanuatu Nursing Council, the MoH’s Human Resources Development (HRD) Unit are also in the process of ensuring all registered nurses have a minimum standard of formal nurse training. A series of bridging courses were rolled out to update the skills of these nurses for completion by the end of 2012.
4.7 Accreditation mechanisms Neither the VCNE nor the VHTI are accredited with any international agencies but both are registered with the Vanuatu Training Council. However, non-registration does not preclude the school from operating, as was the case of the VHTI. While it opened and began enrolling students in 2009, it did not receive course registration from the Council until 2012. Every two to three years, the Council carries out registration maintenance audits.
4.8 In-service and continuing professional education In-service and continuing professional education (CPE) is recognized as a necessary part of health workforce development and is included in the Human 18 Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
The Ministry of Education’s Training and Scholarships Coordination Unit notifies ministries of available scholarships at the start of each year. Each ministry identifies its priorities and makes offers to health officers. All applications are passed through the Human Resources Department at the MoH and applicants are screened through the Health Training Committee.
In 2003, it was reported there were plans to make CPE compulsory for registration renewal. It was also reported that by increasing the professional association’s involvement in-service training, opportunities to update skills would be greatly improved (Ministry of Health, 2003). However, so far, there has been no change to the previous arrangements and CPE remains voluntary.
5. Human resources for health (HRH) utilization 5.1 Recruitment The Public Service Commission is responsible for creating establishment posts and recruitment. Provincial governments identify their workforce needs and notify the Human Resources Department at the MoH. They, in turn, notify the PSC of staffing gaps and all recruitment is carried out centrally. Health workers at the MoH are employed on permanent, or temporary contracts, or on a daily rate basis. All staff are hired on a full time basis and there are no part-time or casual relief staff to cover sick leave, maternity leave, annual leave or other absences (Ministry of Health, 2003). A bilateral agreement between Vanuatu and the Solomon Islands provided for the latter to send nurses to Vanuatu on a fixed-term basis. Although 29 nurses agreed to the transfer, the scheme faced difficulties because the Solomon Islands Public Service Commission had made no provision for the nurses to take three years’ unpaid leave. This meant that, when they returned home, they would have had to start again at the base salary rate despite the experience they had accrued (Buchan, 2011). The PSC in the Solomon Islands has since amended its Public Service Staff Manual to allow the nurses to work in Vanuatu. Ultimately, 24 nurses started a 3-year contract in April 2012. They were initially contracted to work in Vila Central Hospital but have since gone on to fill gaps in other areas. This scheme was seen to be of advantage to both nations as the Solomon Islands have an oversupply of nurses and there is a critical shortage in Vanuatu. However, it proved to be a short-sighted policy decision with several serious implications. The fact that nurses from the Solomon Islands are paid substantially more than ni-Vanuatu nurses increased pressure on an already overstretched budget at the MoH. There was little consultation with the Nursing Council which was concerned that foreign workers were being prioritized over local nurses, especially as nurses graduating from the Vanuatu College of Nursing Education in 2011 have been unable to find jobs due to a lack of vacancies.
5.2 Deployment and distribution policies and mechanisms Staff turnover and stability Staff turnover is mostly due to the ageing of the workforce, rather than migration. The compulsory retirement age is 55 but this has not been strictly enforced due to the government’s lack of funds for severance pay. Nevertheless, the number of staff retiring is increasing as the workforce ages and many are retiring due ill health. It is estimated that 40 health workers will retire each year (Ministry of Health, 2003; 2011b). Shortages of health workers occur across all cadres, but are critical in the nursing workforce. The production of nurses falls far short of replacing those who are retiring, let alone keeping up with increasing population demands. The number of nurses is set to decrease greatly in the short to medium term and a shortage crisis is imminent (Kafoa, 2011). Each year, an estimated 35 nurses exit the workforce, but only approximately 30 students enrol in the nurse training school. Furthermore, there is no guarantee that all 30 will complete the course and graduate. Attrition It was reported in the Second Health Workforce Plan 2004–2013 that attrition of non-retiring staff in Vanuatu has traditionally been low, ranging between 0.5% and Republic of Vanuatu 19
1.5% each year. The public service has historically been a desirable occupation and resignations are rare (Ministry of Health, 2003). Anecdotally, there have only been 3–4 resignations every few years and greater attrition is due to retirement. The number of nurses retiring compared to those graduating is 2:1 (AusAID, 2009b). This affects the capacity and quality of health services. For example, the main referral hospitals, require 4–5 midwives on each shift, but only 1–2 are available (Ministry of Health, 2011b). Average number of hours worked per week per HRH category Paid overtime is only allowed in a few cadres, and only in Vila Central and Northern District hospitals. Laboratory workers, radiologists and theatre staff are entitled to 1.25 times the normal hourly rate for each extra hour worked. Some staff in other wards, such as maternity, are provided with time off in lieu of paid overtime, but many nurses in these wards do not feel this is an adequate remuneration. The implications of paying overtime, as well as other allowances including travel, shift and acting allowances, are significant as there is considerable overspending of the MoH budget on wages and salaries. However, more details on the average number of overtime hours worked, including which cadres complete the most overtime and the financial repercussions, are not available (Table 14). Absenteeism Immediate supervisors monitor absenteeism which is then reported in performance appraisals. Staff who are consistently absent without valid reason, are given warning letters and can have their salaries deducted. However, reliable information on absenteeism is not available. Motivation Low motivation of health workers in Vanuatu has been attributed (Henderson & Tulloch, 2008) to: • weak supervisory systems, particularly in rural areas; • a lack of clear career pathways; • the perception that salaries and remuneration are not adequate; • benefits not being given based on merit; • inconsistency in allocating awards for good performance and disciplining of poor performance; • inadequate facilities and shortages of drugs/equipment; • lack of in-service training; 20 Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
• mismatch in skills and tasks; • an ageing workforce increasing the burden on those who remain; • the increasing burden of noncommunicable diseases; • increased referrals to VCH and NDH. Poor transport options to enable the efficient referral of patients have also been cited as causing low motivation (Henderson & Tulloch, 2008; Ministry of Health, 2003; Ministry of Health & WHO, 2007). It has been highlighted that allowing health workers to practice in both public and private sectors would improve their morale and ability to generate income (Ministry of Health, 2003). Currently, at least two doctors are in dual practice roles. The PSC’s Public Service Staff Manual outlines the terms and conditions of employment for all public service staff. Health workers are entitled to a range of allowances and leave, including those outlined in Table 14. Management structure There is a lack of systemic coordination between the VCNE, MoH and PSC to determine training numbers, training needs of educators, succession planning and career development (Buchan, 2011). The PSC is responsible for the implementation and administration of the Employment Act. It sets salaries, staffing establishments, grades posts, makes appointment and promotion decisions, approves overseas training, resolves employment disputes and discipline issues. The Public Service Staff Manual sets out guidelines and employment conditions for all public servants (Ministry of Health, 2003). Supervisory mechanisms Currently, health centres are responsible for supervising dispensaries and aid posts in their catchment areas (Ministry of Health, 2010a). Supervisory checklist tools and coaching guidelines have been developed with the assistance of the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) to improve and strengthen supervision as part of the ‘Strengthening the Needs-Based In-Service Training for Community Health Nurses (2011–2014)’ project. Facilities, and access to essential equipment and supplies/resources In 2005, the MoH conducted a comprehensive review of infrastructure, facilities and equipment. It
Table 14. Selected allowances and leave for public health-service staff Allowance/ leave type Eligible health workers Amount
Overtime pay or time in lieu
Laboratory workers Radiologists Theatre staff All other health workers Staff working 18:00–06:00 Monday–Friday, weekends or public holidays Staff on 24-hour standby, including laboratory technicians, theatre staff, medical imaging technicians, doctors and nurse practitioners Staff that take on temporary higher responsibilities longer than 10 days (or 20 days for directors general)
1.25 times the hourly rate for each extra hour worked 1.25 hours off for each additional hour worked VUV 1500 per month for regular alternating shifts or VUV 3500 per month for regular night shift workers Extra 25% on top of normal salary, including 7.5% for on-call waiting time VUV 60 000–180 000 depending on pay grade
Shift allowances On-call allowances Acting allowances Resettlement allowances
One-off Permanent Posting Allowances (VUV 50 000) Staff needing to move residences when posted in and a new position One-off Establishment Allowance (VUV 30 000) Required for in-service, or those completing duties or studies away from normal work location requiring overnight stays Domestic: VUV 10 000 per day for first seven days and VUV 5000 for each day after that Overseas: VUV 15 000–50 000 per day depending on destination and pay grade In-service travel or working away from home requiring overnight stay: VUV 2000 per day If no house is available, staff are given a housing allowance of up to VUV 50 000 per month
Travel allowances
Government housing/ Staff working outside Port Vila or Luganville housing allowances Remote allowances Special skills allowance Child allowances Allowances to support PSCapproved training courses Leave without pay Annual leave Sabbatical leave Sick leave Maternity leave Compassionate leave Family leave
Officers posted to remote areas (defined as being not frequented by regular shipping, far from VUV 10 000 per month airstrips and all other forms of communication) Staff with special or critical skills Permanent officers All health workers Permanent staff Daily rate workers Permanent staff Temporary staff All staff All staff Female staff VUV 120 000–2 million per year VUV 2000 per child up to a maximum of VUV 48 000 per year Courses <12 months: Full salaries paid Courses >12 months: Daily allowance rate (provided course is not fully funded by a donor) Up to six months on grounds of urgent private affairs or on compassionate grounds At least 12 months’ service: 21 days Less than 12 months’ service: Proportional to the service completed at rate of 1.75 working days for each completed month of service Up to one year in order to take up duties or functions outside the public service which are in the public interest (e.g. providing service to an NGO involved in community development work) 21 days for each consecutive period of 12 months Permanent staff: 12 weeks at full pay Temporary/daily rated staff: 12 weeks at half pay Nursing mothers also entitled to one hour per day to feed their child (this is counted as a working hour) 10 days on full pay for death of parent, child, sibling or husband/wife One day on full pay (at discretion of director of department) for death of other close relatives Permanent staff: Two days’ full pay Temporary/daily rate staff: One day’s full pay One day’s full pay
Permanent staff on occasion of death of relative All staff on marriage Male staff on birth of child
International meetings: Special leave for duration of event Special leave for Permanent officer selected for an international Meetings, conferences, conventions, training events: Up to five days but not sporting, cultural or provincial sporting team, a representative of a more than duration of meeting and religious events cultural or religious body to represent Vanuatu Participation as a competitor or official in the Vanuatu Provincial Games: Leave up to 14 days, but not more than duration of games Source: Public Service Commission, 2008.
Republic of Vanuatu
21
estimated that VUV 160 billion would be needed to replace equipment (Ministry of Health, 2011b). At the time, the budget allocated for maintaining assets was low at 1.5%. However, despite the recommendation made in the infrastructure review that 4% of the value of the assets should be set aside for maintaining, and replacing facilities and equipment (Ministry of Health, 2003), as of 2012, underspending in capital investments had not improved. The development of MoH facilities is planned on population and accessibility factors. In areas where transportation is difficult, there may be more facilities per capita (Ministry of Health, 2003). Communities develop and maintain their facilities through their health committees (AusAID, 2009b). In 2010, in addition to the computers already made available to VCH and NDH, five health facilities were supplied with 30 computers and 10 laptops, and connected to the Internet. These facilities included Lenakel Hospital, Lolowai Hospital, Norsup Hospital, Lamap Health Centre and Torba Health Centre. In comparison, other health facilities that are still not connected are at a much greater disadvantage when collecting health data (Government of Vanuatu, 2011a). The Central Medical Stores are responsible for procurement and distribution of essential supplies to the five provincial hospitals. The hospitals request supplies every two months and are responsible for distributing them to rural health facilities in their catchment zones (Government of Vanuatu, 2011a). Although JICA supports Vanuatu with the procurement of drugs, there are still shortages in many health facilities.
5.3 Unemployment The paradox in the public health sector is that in parallel with the shortage of health workers, there is a lack of funds to absorb the graduates who want to enter the system. For example, much needed nursing graduates from the 2011 class were unable to find work immediately. However, funding for approximately 20 graduates has been found and it is expected that they will start work in mid-November 2012. Funding has also been procured to ensure the 2012 graduating class will also find posts. However, these posts are not new; severance entitlements have been paid to some older health workers to persuade them to retire and create the necessary vacancies for young health workers. Currently, the MoH is attempting to match existing and new establishment posts under the new governance structure. Once this process is finished, it is hoped that the vacancies will be identified and approximately 300 extra posts will be created. However, as the MoH is aiming to absorb the unpaid community health workers into the new structure, they are likely to take up many of the extra posts, which will not help new graduates entering the labour force.
5.4 Employment of health workers in the private sector The private sector contribution to health services is relatively small, with an estimated 17 health facilities in the two urban centres of Port Vila and Luganville. These facilities largely serve expatriate communities and high-income earners who are able to afford the higher medical costs. Consultations at the lowest range are normally VUV 1400–1900, excluding laboratory tests and medicines. Some government officials have moved to private sector posts because of the attractive working conditions they offer. It is estimated that two doctors currently work in both the public and private health sectors.
22
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
6. Financing HRH 6.1 HRH expenditure Between 1998 and 2003, health personnel expendi ture accounted for 56.6–62.0% of the MoH’s total budget. The government is looking to reduce personnel expenditure to less than 60% to release money for resources and maintenance of assets (Ministry of Health, 2003). In 2012, it was reported there was a large overspend on salaries and wages. The allocated budget for wages and salaries was approximately VUV 1 billion for the 2012 calendar year, but by the end of July, the MoH had overspent to the tune of VUV 60 million. Allowances, including overtime, acting, shift and travel allowances are significant contributors to the shortfall. The MoH is considering several measures in an effort to meet its budget allocation. Such measures may include: • freezing recruitment of new staff; • re-prioritizing Phase 1 of the new governance structure; • reviewing contracts; • screening and monitoring costly allowances; • cutting the operational budget; and • privatizing of some selected hospital and administrative services. According to the Second Health Workforce Plan 2004– 2013, it is projected that between 2005 and 2013, an extra 103 new posts will be created, amounting to a 14% increase. At 2004 rates, it is estimated that the total cost of the projected workforce growth for these years will be VUV 75 million. However, this does not take into consideration growth in non-professional workers. Domestic and ancillary services will need to increase in parallel with an increase in the professional health workforce (Ministry of Health, 2003). It also does not take into consideration increased training costs. A Ministry of Finance representative has stated that over the past five years, the MoH has consistently circumnavigated regular recruitment protocols to appoint staff. This has led to over expenditure, and other ministries’ budgetary allocations have been used to cover the shortfall and prevent hospital closures.
6.2 Health workers’ remuneration Salaries for public sector health workers are determined by the PSC and outlined in the Public Service Staff Manual (Public Service Commission, 2008). There is no clear career or salary pathway, with little difference in salaries between graduates and those with years of experience. As yet, there is no performance-based payment mechanism, but an improved salary structure linked to performance would encourage career development, retention and recruitment (Buchan, 2011). In addition to a base salary, there are incentives and allowances for rural postings. Government housing is provided to those working outside Port Vila and Luganville. If no housing is available, staff are given a housing allowance of up to VUV 50 000 per month. Extra allowances are also given to rural staff amounting to VUV 10 000 per month. Expatriate health workers are paid significantly higher wages than local ni-Vanuatu. For example, Australian specialists are paid the equivalent of Australian wages, which are very high when compared to local salaries and have the potential to cause resentment in local health workers. In 2010, the four expatriate consultants in the country cost VUV 80 million, approximately 950 000 Australian dollars (AUD) 2. Nevertheless, the Vanuatu cannot afford to stop this support as this would reduce the available skills base and amount of the supervision given to young medical doctors (Buchan, 2011). The 24 Solomon Islands nurses who were contracted in 2012 as part of a bilateral agreement between the two countries are also paid significantly higher wages than local nurses. Before the new governance structure is approved, the PSC has asked the MoH to conduct an independent review of health-worker remuneration levels and to assess whether they are proportionate to working conditions. Many health workers, particularly nurses, feel their salaries are too low in comparison to other public servants and want their salaries to be at least on a par with police officers and teachers. However, the data collected for this report indicate that entry2
1 AUD = US$ 1.04 (1 June 2013).
Republic of Vanuatu
23
Table 15. Average monthly income, by professional category/cadre, 2012 Professional categories/cadres Profession Average monthly salary (VUV) Ratio of income to GDP per capita (VUV 305 175)
Health professionals Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Graduate/registered/ professional nurses Nurse aides Dentists Medical practitioners Senior consultants Registered nurses Senior nurses Nurse in charge Nurse aides 164 640 202 860 67 620 76 440 105 840 44 100 147 000 111 720 114 660 152 875 76 440 111 720 114 660 114 660 76 440 114 660 114 660 114 660 94 080 126 420 76 440 123 480 120 540 88 200 58 800 120 540 35 280 70 560 105 840 1:1.85 1:1.50 1:4.51 1:3.99 1:2.88 1:6.92 1:2.08 1:2.73 1:2.66 1:2.00 1:3.99 1:2.73 1:2.66 1:2.66 1:3.99 1:2.66 1:2.66 1:2.66 1:3.24 1:2.41 1:3.99 1:2.47 1:2.53 1:3.46 1:5.19 1:2.53 1:8.65 1:4.33 1:2.88
Dentists Dental technicians and Dental technicians and assistants therapists Pharmacists Pharmacists Principal pharmacists Pharmacy assistants Pharmaceutical technicians and assistants Pharmacy technicians Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians Physiotherapists Nutritionists and dieticians Health service managers Laboratory technicians X-ray Physiotherapists Nutritionists and dieticians Public health programme coordinators Provincial health managers Human resource managers Senior human resource officers Accounts manager Senior accounts manager Information technology IT support officer (system administrator) Assistant secretary Executive secretary Constable Sergeant Inspector
Health management personnel not elsewhere classified
Non-health professionals not elsewhere specified
Non-health technicians and associate professionals not elsewhere classified
Professionals from other sectors Police officers Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
level nurses are paid almost twice as much as entrylevel police officers (Table 15). A key factor in the nurses’ dissatisfaction is the lack of a clear career
path, unlike teachers. The MoH has asked the WHO and AusAID for technical assistance but a review has not yet been conducted.
24
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
7. Governance of HRH 7.1 HRH policies and plans The Second Health Workforce Plan 2004–2013 is the current HRH plan. A Working Group was established with the previous Director of Planning and Administration as the chair. It included key units under the former Directorate of Planning and Administration, as well as representatives from the Southern and Northern Health Care directorates, and the Directorate of Public Health. Crucially, it did not include contributions from the training schools or from other government departments that play a role in health workforce development, such as the Ministry of Finance and the Public Service Commission (Ministry of Health, 2003). The Directorate of Planning and Administration is responsible for the monitoring and evaluation of the Second Workforce Plan 2004–2013. The Working Group that developed the plan meets quarterly to review implementation. Initially, it was envisaged that the Working Group would undertake a major review every two years to measure progress against objectives outlined in the plan (Ministry of Health, 2003). To date, only one review was conducted in 2005. Subsequent reviews were not conducted because key positions within the Directorate of Planning and Administration were dissolved. In addition, large sections of the workforce plan have not been implemented due to the lack of a HR unit and staff (which has now been rectified), disconnects between the health service and health workforce planning, and a mismatch between production and deployment of health workers (Office of Human Resource Development Training, 2010). Details of the 2005 major review could not be accessed for this report. A new HRH plan is to be developed in preparation for the expiration of the current plan. It is known that two of the key objectives in the new plan are to integrate the Cuban medical brigade and training programme and, through the Pacific Technical Assistance in Medicine scheme, reduce the country’s reliance on specialist doctors by developing more ni-Vanuatu specialists.
7.2 Policy development, planning and managing for HRH The Human Resources Development Unit, Corporate Services, in the Ministry of Health carries out planning for HRH at the national level. Responsibilities of the HRD Unit include: • day-to-day responsibility for training oversight, coordination and support; • providing secretariat services to the Workforce Training Committee; • communicating with and supporting provincial and hospital training focal persons in planning, implementing and evaluating training as needed; • supporting the development of in-service training modules (including teacher’s notes with curriculum and teaching materials, and student handouts) to facilitate standardized training with accurate technical content; • providing administrative assistance to support scholarship applications and maintenance of the training database; and • compiling and reviewing training reports (required on completion of all training) to support the improvement of the quality of courses and shared learning (Ministry of Health, 2004). There were six staff in 2012 in the central office, made up of two staff in human resource development, and four in human resource management. Each hospital has human resource officers that oversee personnel issues such as leave. The system is centralized and there is an unwillingness to decentralize health sector management, despite the introduction of a decentralization policy and relevant legislation that came into force in 1994 (Buchan, 2011). Recruitment, dismissals and salary determination are the responsibility of central government, through the PSC. Local-level service delivery planning is completed using manuals and handbooks to guide the work. The Health Sector Strategy for Vanuatu 2010–2016 outlines a set of HRH objectives as part of a range of health system changes. It has identified staff shortages, deficiencies in HRH policy planning and management, as well as the need to develop career structures, improve the HRH information system, establish a Health Practitioner Board, implement
Republic of Vanuatu
25
performance management systems and review salary structures (Buchan, 2011). There are no systematic or regular reviews of provincial performance, and there is no system of primary care incentives for individual health workers or community members attending health facilities (AusAID, 2009b). The national government conducts evaluations of health workers’ performance and undertakes disciplinary reviews. Despite the existence of a schedule of supervisory outreach, visits are not undertaken at the regular intervals due to staffing, transportation and funding constraints. Good performances are not rewarded equally and poor performances are not disciplined consistently, causing frustration among health workers (Ministry of Health & WHO, 2007). There is a need to improve coordination between government, civil society and donors in healthcare delivery and the health information system (Government of Vanuatu, 2011a). To this end, the directors general in each ministry meet weekly providing a formal forum for improving government coordination. The Joint Partnership Working Group holds monthly meetings with the major donor partners. Participants include AusAID, the Secretariat of the Pacific Community (SPC), United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF), United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA), WHO and the World Bank. High-level meetings are also held with donor partners and directors general approximately twice a year.
Practitioners Board (Ministry of Health, 2003). Applicants must hold a qualification from a recognized teaching institution and/or show they have the experience and capabilities to practice that profession. The Board is also responsible for maintaining professional conduct and discipline. Registration is required yearly and capabilities are assessed before re-licensing. The Nursing Council is responsible for establishing and implementing a standard for registered nurses, midwives and nurse practitioners. It is also responsible for developing the syllabus and regulations for nurse training (Office of Human Resource Development Training, 2010). However, there are no regulatory processes or competency standards. The principals of the nursing schools assess each graduate’s readiness for registration, namely, the completion of a nursing programme and two years’ probation. Registration is required annually. Foreign nurses need to apply for registration to practise but this is not competency based. There is no allowance in the Nurses Act to de-register nurses for unsafe practice. Instead, nurses are suspended from their job and re-employed under supervision (JCU & AUT, 2011; Ministry of Health, 2003). The Office of the Director General has asked that the Nursing Council be flexible in conferring licences because of the shortage of nurses. It is hoped that by 2015, there will be a surplus of nurses and standards may be enforced more strictly (Ministry of Health, 2010c). No other health workers are required to be registered.
7.3 Professional regulation The Health Practitioners Act 1984 and Nurses Act 2000 provide the legal framework for the registration of health practitioners. The Health Practitioners Board and the Vanuatu Nursing Council are the mechanisms t h ro u g h w h i c h t h e s e a c t s a re i m p l e m e n t e d (Government of Vanuatu, 1984). Registration with both the Board and the Council is compulsory in order to practice in the public sector (Kafoa, 2011). However, these entities do not use a standard approach to assessing foreign health workers. The Health Practitioners Board is responsible for licensing doctors, dentists, physiotherapists, radiographers, osteopaths and medical laboratory technicians. The Control of Pharmacists Act 1988 is not fully implemented and a Pharmacists Practitioners Commission has not yet been established. Thus, pharmacists are also registered under the Health
7.4 HRH information systems As it stands, the human resources database for health workers is incomplete and outdated. This has hampered policy planning, recruitment and succession planning. Furthermore, a lack of proper job descriptions was highlighted as a problem in the Health Sector Strategy Plan, 2010–2016 (Buchan, 2011; Ministry of Health, 2010b). The human resources information database system is currently being populated with HRH data. However, the hard copies of this personnel information comes from survey forms sent out to health officers to complete and return. The response rate has been poor. In addition, staff require training and support to develop regular reporting systems (Buchan, 2011).
26
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
The Ministry of Finance also has a Human Resource Management Information System (HRMIS) that has records of all public service staff. However, the two ministries appear to be duplicating the effort needed to monitor the health workforce.
7.5 Health workforce requirements The Health Sector Strategy 2010–2016 outlines key indicators to be achieve by 2016 (Ministry of Health, 2010b). These include:
• 1 doctor per 15 000 population (up from 1 per 30 000 population in 2008) • 1 nurse per 200 population (up from 1 per 600 population) • 1 allied health worker per 7500 population (up from 1 per 60 000 population) • 1 public health officer per 20 000 population (up from 1 per 30 000 population). National Statistics Office (2010) projections show that, in order to reach the key indicators outlined in the
Table 16. Projected health professional category/cadre workforce needs to maintain 2012 levels in the next 10 and 20 years Health professional group/cadre 2012 Replacements needed in 10 years (2022) Replacements needed in 20 years (2032)
Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Graduate/registered/professional nurses Midwives Nurse aides Dentists Dental technicians and assistants Pharmacists Pharmaceutical technicians and assistants Medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Physiotherapists Nutritionists and dieticians Biomedical engineers Medical and dental prosthetic technicians Environmental and occupational health and hygiene professionals Health associate professionals not elsewhere specified Non-health professionals not elsewhere classified Non-health technicians and associate professionals not elsewhere classified Health service managers Health management personnel not elsewhere classified Community health workerss Traditional and complementary medicine associate professionals Personal care workers in health services not elsewhere classified Service and sales workers Clerical support workers Domestic and ancillary support workers Total Source: Ministry of Health (2010b).
17 29 56 279 62 152 7 10 6 23 12 59 3 2 2 2 36 17 53 5 9 31 206 2 8 13 29 131 1261
5 9 34 97 35 53 1 3 2 7 4 18 1 0 1 2 10 7 22 1 6 19 124 1 3 3 10 64 541
10 20 49 182 58 103 4 7 4 16 7 37 1 2 1 2 27 13 39 2 9 30 206 2 7 10 19 113 980
Republic of Vanuatu
27
Health Sector Strategy 2010–2016, there will need to be 19 doctors, 1387 nurses, 37 allied health and 14 public health officers employed in 2016 to serve a population of 277 394. The current number of doctors (46), allied health (126) and public health officers (359) employed is on track to meet this target, but the number of nurses falls far short of this target (549, including nurse aides). An extra 892 nurses will be needed by 2016 to replace those who will be retiring. Projecting health workforce requirements is difficult as attrition data are unavailable and it is difficult to
determine exit rates. However, assuming that the retirement age of 55 is enforced from 2013, the current number of health workers whose ages are unknown average out across the next 20 years, and attrition from resignations is not factored into the equation, Vanuatu will need to employ 541 extra health workers over the next 10 years (to 2022). It will also need another 439 health workers in between 2023 and 2032 to maintain the current health workerto-population ratio (Table 16).
8. Concluding remarks The health workforce situation in Vanuatu is reaching a critical stage, with severe shortages in health workers rendering the country unlikely to meet all the health Millennium Development Goals by 2015, especially Goal 5: Improving maternal health. The dispersion of the population across a vast area greatly increases the cost of funding health services. Many who leave the workforce are doing so because of age and illness, rather than a desire to emigrate. Anecdotally, the rate of resignations is very low; with many ni-Vanuatu believing work with the public service is highly desirable. External migration is not as prevalent in Vanuatu when compared to other Pacific Island countries and brain drain is not a significant issue. Production of health workers is highly inadequate, but without a large boost in financial support to the two health personnel training schools, it will be very difficult to increase the number of locally produced nurses. Unless the problem of production deficits is rectified, the steady population growth and demand for services will far outstrip the supply of health workers.
28
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
References ADB (2009). Vanuatu economic report 2009: Accelerating reform. Manila, Asian Development Bank. AusAID (2009a). Working Paper 3: Vanuatu country report. Canberra, Australian Agency for International Development. AusAID (2009b). Australian aid to health service delivery in Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands and Vanuatu: Evaluation report . Canberra, Australian Agency for International Development. Buchan J (2011). Vanuatu health sector human resource planning support. Canberra, AusAID Health Resource Facility (HRF). Government of Vanuatu (1984). Health Practitioners Act, 1984. Port Vila, Ministry of Health. Government of Vanuatu (2005). Vanuatu: A situation analysis of children, women & youth. Port Vila. Government of Vanuatu (2011a). Ministry of Health. Port Vila (http://www.governmentofvanuatu.gov.vu/ index.php/government/health, accessed 7 June 2013). Government of Vanuatu (2011b). Nursing school gets educational material from Rotary . Port Vila (http://www.governmentofvanuatu.gov.vu/index. php?option=com_content&view=article&id=173 :nursing-school-gets-educational-material-fromrotary&catid=69:latest-news&Itemid=134, accessed 7 June 2013). Government of Vanuatu (2012). University of the South Pacific (USP) has agreed to assist Vanuatu Institute of Teachers Education (VITE). Port Vila (http://www. governmentofvanuatu.gov.vu/index.php/news-recentnews/nationaregional--internation/latest-news/187niversity-of-the-south-pacific-usp-has-agreed-toassist-vanuatu-institute-of-teachers-education-vite%3E, accessed 7 June 2013). Henderson L, Tulloch J (2008). Incentives for retaining and motivating health workers in Pacific and Asian countries. Human Resources for Health, 6(18). JCU, AUT (2011). Nursing project summary tables. Paper presented to Pacific Human Resources for Health Association (PHRHA), Nadi, 9–11 February 2011. Singapore/Auckland, James Cook University/ Auckland University of Technology. Kafoa B (2011). P acific post secondary education strategy: Health sector note . Canberra, Australian Agency for International Development (AusAID). Maoate K, Jensen S, Sorensen D (2011). New Zealand medical treatment scheme. Strengthening Specialised Clinical Services in the Pacific (SSCSIP) Program. Nadi, Fiji. Ministry of Health (2003). Second health workforce plan 2004–2013. Port Vila, Government of Vanuatu. Ministry of Health (2004). Health workforce training plan 2004–2008. Port Vila, Government of Vanuatu. Ministry of Health (2010a). Brief presentation on Vanuatu’s Ministry of Health functions, achievements and challenges. Paper presented at the Pacific Senior Health Officials Network Meeting (PSHON), Port Vila, Vanuatu, 15–17 September 2010 . Port Vila, Government of Vanuatu. Ministry of Health (2010b). Health sector strategy 2010–2016. Port Vila, Government of Vanuatu. Ministry of Health (2010c). Separation of training institutions within the Ministry of Health . Port Vila, Office of the Director General, Government of Vanuatu. Ministry of Health (2011a). Country situation on human resources for health (HRH). Identifying HRH issues, challenges and needs. Paper presented at the Pacific Human Resources for Health Alliance (PHRHA) Meeting, Nadi, Fiji, February 2011. Port Vila, Government of Vanuatu. Ministry of Health (2011b). New project initiative (NPI) 2011. Overseas nurse training – Solomon Islands. Port Vila. Government of Vanuatu. Ministry of Health, World Health Organization (2007). Vanuatu National Health Accounts 2005. Port Vila, Government of Vanuatu.
Republic of Vanuatu
29
National Statistics Office (2010). 2009 National Population and Housing Census: Basic Tables Report. Volume 1. Port Vila, Government of Vanuatu. Negin J (2011). Inter-island referrals and human resource planning in the Solomon Islands. A policy brief for the Ministry of Health and Medical Services. Sydney, University of Sydney. Office of Human Resource Development Training (2010). Current status of human resources within the Ministry of Health. Port Vila, Ministry of Health, Government of Vanuatu. Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat (2011). 2011 Pacific regional MDGs tracking report. Suva. ProMedical (2012). Home . Port Vila (http://www. promedical.com.vu/, accessed 7 June 2013). Public Service Commission (2008). Public service staff manual. Port Vila, Government of Vanuatu. Secretariat of the Pacific Community (2011) Pacific island populations - estimates and projections of demographic indicators for selected years (http:// www.spc.int/sdp, accessed on 19/9/2011) South Pacific Smiles (2012). About us, South Pacific Smiles. Port Vila (http://www.southpacificsmiles.com/ Pages/About_Us/About.html, accessed 7 June 2013). SSCSIP (2011). Situational analysis of SCSIP – preliminary findings . Nadi, Fiji, Strengthening
Specialised Clinical Services in the Pacific (SSCSIP) initiative. Token W, Carlot M, Christophe M (2011). Vanuatu Team Cuba Mission Report 3rd–14th September 2011. Port Vila, Ministry of Health. UNDP 2010, Human Development Report 2010. New York, NY, United Nations Development Programme. Vanuatu Tourism Office (2012). Novo Dental opens state of the art clinic in Port Vila. Port Vila (http:// vanuatutourismnews.blogspot.ch/2012/07/novodental-opens-state-of-art-clinic.html, accessed 7 June 2013). WHO (2004). Migration of Skilled Health Personnel in the Pacific Region: A Summary Report. Manila, World Health Organization. WHO (2006). The World Health Report 2006: Working together for health. Geneva, World Health Organization. WHO (2012). Western Pacific country health information profiles: 2011 revision. Manila, World Health Organization Western Pacific Regional Office (WPRO). World Bank (2012) (online database). Vanuatu data. Washington DC (http://data.worldbank.org/country/ vanuatu, accessed 7 June 2013).
30
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
Annexes Annex A. Ministry of Health organizational chart
Minister for Health
Public Service Commission
Director General
Director Public Health
Director Northern Health Care Group
Director Southern Health Care Group
Executive Officer
Postgraduate Medical Council Centre for Nursing Education Nursing Council Central Medical Store
Corporate Services & Planning Manager, Human Resources Manager, Finance Donor Coordinator Manager, Assets Internal Auditor Health Planner Development IT Officer
Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
Republic of Vanuatu
31
Annex B. Distribution of public sector health workers by category/cadre and gender, 2012 Health professional group/cadre Total Gender not registered Female Female %
Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Graduate/registered/professional nurses Midwives Nurse aides/nurse assistants Dentists Dental technicians and assistants Pharmacists Pharmaceutical technicians and assistants Medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Physiotherapists Nutritionists and dieticians Biomedical engineers Medical and dental prosthetic technicians Environmental and occupational health and hygiene professionals Health associate professionals not elsewhere specified Non-health professionals not elsewhere classified Non-health technicians and associate professionals not elsewhere classified Health service managers Health management personnel not elsewhere classified Community health workers Traditional and complementary medicine associate professionals Personal-care workers in health services not elsewhere classified Service and sales workers Clerical support workers Domestic and ancillary support workers Total ND, not determined. Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
17 29 56 279 62 152 7 10 6 23 12 59 3 2 2 2 36 17 53 5 9 31 206 2 8 13 29 131 1261
1 4 ND 3 2 11 2 ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 1 ND 2 ND ND 0 1 27
6 8 15 175 58 91 2 4 4 12 3 15 2 1 ND ND 5 3 28 1 3 12 88 ND 3 4 24 63 630
38 27 26 63 94 60 29 40 67 52 25 25 67 50 0 0 16 29 49 20 33 38 43 0 38 36 83 47 50
32
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
Annex C. Distribution of public sector health workers by category/cadre and age, 2012 Health professional groups/cadre Total Not < 30 known 30– 34 35– 39 40– 44 45– 49 50– 54
55– > 60 59 0 0 8 23 8 3 0 2 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 2 3 0 1 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 2 16 74 6 1 0 4 9 3 3 0 0 0 2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 28 2
Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Graduate/ registered/ professional nurses Midwives Nurse aides Dentists Dental technicians and assistants Pharmacists Pharmaceutical technicians and assistants Medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Physiotherapists Nutritionists and dieticians Biomedical engineers Medical and dental prosthetic technicians Environmental and occupational health and hygiene professionals Health associate professionals not elsewhere specified Non-health professionals not elsewhere classified Non-health technicians and associate professionals not elsewhere classified Health service managers Health management personnel not elsewhere classified Community health workers Traditional and complementary medicine associate professionals Personal care workers in health services not elsewhere classified Service and sales workers Clerical support workers Domestic and ancillary support workers Total Proportion (%) Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
17 29 56 279 62 152 7 10 6 23 12 59 3 2 2 2 36 17 53 5 9 31 206 2 8 13 29 131 1261 100
1 8 3 15 8 54 2 0 1 1 0 13 1 0 1 0 4 7 11 0 0 2 206 2 0 5 4 24 373 30
6 3 0 48 0 36 1 3 1 4 4 13 0 0 1 0 8 1 7 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 6 10 155 12
1 6 7 49 4 13 2 0 1 3 1 9 2 0 0 0 1 3 7 3 0 0 0 0 0 2 4 8 126 10
1 5 7 49 8 15 2 2 1 5 0 9 0 0 0 0 7 1 8 0 1 5 0 0 1 1 2 17 147 12
4 3 7 30 12 13 0 2 1 4 3 5 0 2 0 0 8 2 5 1 2 5 0 0 3 4 5 22 143 11
1 2 9 30 10 10 0 1 0 3 0 3 0 0 0 0 1 2 7 1 2 5 0 0 3 0 2 17 109 9
2 2 11 26 9 5 0 0 1 1 2 4 0 0 0 0 4 1 6 0 4 8 0 0 0 0 4 16 106 8
Republic of Vanuatu
33
Annex D. Distribution of public sector health workers by category/cadre and by urban/ rural areas, 2012 Urban Health professional group/cadre Total % HW /1000 population (pop. 62 664) *
%
Rural HW*/1000 population (pop. 188 998)
Generalist medical practitioners Specialist medical practitioners Advanced practice nurses Graduate/registered/ professional nurses Midwives Nurse aides/nurse assistants Dentists Dental technicians and assistants Pharmacists Pharmaceutical technicians and assistants Medical imaging and therapeutic equipment technicians Medical and pathology laboratory technicians Physiotherapists Nutritionists and dieticians Biomedical engineers Medical and dental prosthetic technicians Environmental and occupational health and hygiene professionals Health associate professionals not elsewhere specified Non-health professionals not elsewhere classified Non-health technicians and associate professionals not elsewhere classified Health service managers Health management personnel not elsewhere classified Community health workers Traditional and complementary medicine associate professionals Personal care workers in health services not elsewhere classified Service and sales workers Clerical support workers Domestic and ancillary support workers Total * HW, health worker. Source: Ministry of Health, 2012.
17 29 56 279 62 152 7 10 6 23 12 59 3 2 2 2 36 17 53 5 9 31 206 2 8 13 29 131 1261
82.4 96.6 26.8 48.4 46.8 24.3 100 100 83.3 47.8 75.0 35.6 100 100 100 100 33.3 5.9 81.1 40.0 77.8 51.6 0.0 100 87.5 92.3 65.5 63.4 42.3
0.22 0.45 0.24 2.15 0.46 0.59 0.11 0.16 0.08 0.18 0.14 0.34 0.05 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.19 0.02 0.69 0.03 0.11 0.26 0.00 0.03 0.11 0.19 0.30 1.32 8.52
17.6 3.4 73.2 51.6 53.2 75.7 0.0 0.0 16.7 52.2 25.0 64.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 66.7 94.1 18.9 60.0 22.2 48.4 100.0 0.0 12.5 7.7 34.5 36.6 57.7
0.02 0.01 0.22 0.76 0.17 0.61 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.06 0.02 0.20 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.13 0.08 0.05 0.02 0.01 0.08 1.09 0.00 0.01 0.01 0.05 0.25 3.85
34
Human Resources for Health Country Profiles
This publication is available on the Internet at: http://www.wpro.who.int/hrh/ documents/publications/hrh_buffet_country_profiles/en/index.html
ISBN 978 92 4 150391 4